(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48241162)

Background and Fighting Styles

Robert Baratheon (Prime):

Strength and Power: Known for his towering strength, Robert in his prime wielded a massive warhammer with the kind of force that could shatter armor, shield, and bone alike. He was a giant on the battlefield, driven by his indomitable will and sheer physicality, swinging his warhammer with brutal precision. Robert’s power was so legendary that he was said to be capable of ending battles with single, decisive blows.

Ferocity and Battlefield Tactics: Robert was known for an aggressive, forward-driving style. He thrived on the chaos of battle, leveraging his powerful swings and fearless nature to create openings against any opponent. Unyielding in his approach, Robert's tactic often involved overwhelming his enemies quickly, before they had a chance to counter.

Ser Arthur Dayne:

Skill and Technique: Known as the Sword of the Morning, Dayne wielded the mystical greatsword Dawn, forged from a fallen star. His reputation as Westeros’s greatest knight was well earned, given his unparalleled swordsmanship and agility. Dayne was known for his exceptional reflexes, precision, and mastery over his blade, making him a highly versatile and deadly opponent in close combat.

Discipline and Knightly Honor: Dayne fought with honor and restraint, using his technique to maintain control over his engagements. He was methodical, intelligent, and unfazed by his opponent’s reputation, confident in his skill and adaptability. Dayne’s fighting style was fluid and graceful, emphasizing precision over brute force.

Battle Dynamics and Strategies

Initial Approach:

Robert: True to form, Robert would likely open aggressively, seeking to close the distance quickly to bring his warhammer to bear. He’d aim to catch Dayne off guard with a heavy, crushing blow, setting the tone for a brutal, high-stakes fight. His approach would be fast and explosive, with little room for Dayne to dictate the pace.

Dayne: Aware of Robert’s power, Dayne would likely adopt a defensive stance, maintaining distance and relying on his agility to evade Robert’s initial charge. Dayne’s strategy would involve circling and assessing Robert’s movements, probing with quick, precise strikes to test Robert’s reactions without committing too early.

Middle of the Fight:

Robert’s Offensive: Once the initial exchanges begin, Robert would continue with relentless pressure, swinging his warhammer with brutal intent and aiming to keep Dayne off balance. His goal would be to close the gap, forcing Dayne into a defensive posture. However, Robert’s power also requires precision; if his swings miss, he could open himself to a counter from the more agile Dayne.

Dayne’s Counterplay: Recognizing Robert’s intent, Dayne would use Dawn to deflect or parry without absorbing the full impact of Robert’s swings, conserving his strength. Dayne’s agility would be a key advantage here, allowing him to dart in and out, targeting Robert’s exposed areas—particularly his legs or arms—when openings arise. Dayne’s precision would allow him to inflict damage without fully committing, intending to wear Robert down over time.

Clash of Strengths:

Robert’s Resilience: Robert has the physical endurance to withstand long, grueling fights, and his resilience would serve him well as he takes minor hits and keeps pressing forward. This stamina would allow him to remain a constant threat, preventing Dayne from getting too comfortable. However, his reliance on power moves could drain him over time, particularly if he doesn’t land significant blows.

Dayne’s Adaptability: Dayne’s adaptable fighting style and tactical awareness would allow him to shift strategies, avoiding Robert’s direct assaults and striking at weak points as they become evident. Dayne’s honed instincts would lead him to exploit any loss of momentum from Robert, allowing him to dance around the larger man’s brute force.

Potential Turning Points and Possible Outcomes

Robert Overwhelms Dayne:

If Robert’s relentless offensive succeeds in landing a direct blow on Dayne, it could spell the end of the match. A single, well-placed strike from Robert’s warhammer would likely crush through Dayne’s defenses, overwhelming even his legendary skill. If Robert were to close the distance, forcing Dayne to engage up close, he could overpower him with sheer physicality, pinning Dayne or disarming him by brute force.

Dayne’s Precision Wins Out:

On the other hand, if Dayne is able to maintain his mobility and avoid a direct confrontation, he could wear down Robert through a series of targeted, calculated strikes. With his skill, Dayne would likely go for strikes to Robert’s legs or arms, limiting his mobility and power over time. If Dayne managed to disarm Robert or exploit his slower recovery times, he could bring the fight under his control, turning it into a test of skill where his agility and precision would reign supreme.

Draw Scenario:

Both warriors are relentless in their own ways—Robert with his resilience and Dayne with his skill. In a situation where neither can land a decisive blow, the match could end in a draw due to exhaustion or mutual respect. Given their knightly codes, it’s plausible they might reach an unspoken acknowledgment of each other’s strength, especially if neither is able to overcome the other definitively.

Final Analysis: Likely Winner

In this clash, the odds slightly favor Ser Arthur Dayne due to his superior technique, agility, and ability to adapt to different combat styles. While Robert’s raw power would make him a formidable threat, especially in close quarters, Dayne’s precision, speed, and finesse would allow him to avoid the worst of Robert’s attacks and exploit his openings over time. Given the cage format, which limits space but doesn’t neutralize Dayne’s agility entirely, Dayne’s skill and composure would likely give him the edge, though he’d emerge from the fight bruised and bloodied.

Ultimately, Arthur Dayne could win by outlasting Robert’s power-based strategy, waiting for the opportune moment to disable him through targeted strikes, and ending the fight with a tactical finish rather than brute force.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48241165)

jaime’s arrogance would be his undoing against either of them; he’s too dependent on his reputation, too used to fighting on his own terms. in a cage, against true forces like dayne or robert, he’d be forced to face what he really is: a sword with a sharp edge, but no depth.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48252276)

dayne could keep his distance, evade, and counter—but every miss, every second he fails to put robert down, would bring him closer to exhaustion, closer to one mistake. dayne would need the patience of a saint and the reflexes of a predator to survive long enough to wear robert down. one slip, and it ends in a thunderous instant, no honor, no ceremony, just the finality of that hammer coming down.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48252274)

Edit: Also isn’t this basically the Mountain vs Martell?

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48252300)

In battle, Dayne

In a cage (no weapons or armor) Barathion

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5618214&forum_id=2/#48268164)