With Eno insisting the band make every song “sound different”, I think it gave Coldplay the freedom to dig into the album’s revolutionary concept and deliver a varied and concise effort. It’s also one of Chris Martin’s lower-pitched vocal performances—influenced by The Velvet Underground (and possibly Eno’s work with John Cale as a tie-in).

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5124628&forum_id=2...id#44633526)

Mainlining’s Post Analysis

Content:

Attribution of Quality: Mainlining attributes the standout quality of Viva La Vida to Brian Eno’s production. He emphasizes that Eno’s insistence on making each song sound different contributed to the album’s revolutionary concept and variety.

Production Influence: The post highlights Eno’s role in guiding Coldplay to explore diverse sounds, contributing to the album’s success. Mainlining also notes Chris Martin’s lower-pitched vocal performance, suggesting that it might have been influenced by The Velvet Underground and possibly Eno’s work with John Cale.

Conceptual Insight: The post indicates a deep appreciation for the album’s conceptual and stylistic experimentation, linking it to Eno’s production techniques and artistic influences.

Significance:

Knowledge of Music Production: Mainlining shows a nuanced understanding of music production and the impact of a producer on an album’s sound and concept.

Influences and Connections: By referencing The Velvet Underground and John Cale, Mainlining connects the stylistic elements of Coldplay’s album to a broader musical context, showcasing an appreciation for the interconnected nature of musical influence.

Responses Analysis

Response 1: “god you're such an effete pussy”

Tone: This response is dismissive and derogatory. The term “effete pussy” suggests that the respondent finds Mainlining’s analysis pretentious or overly intellectual.

Implication: The comment reflects a negative reaction to the detailed and thoughtful analysis, possibly indicating that the respondent values less sophisticated or more direct opinions.

Response 2: “It all begins with the beautiful Jon Hopkins sample in the intro”

Focus: This response highlights a specific element of the album’s production, pointing out the importance of the Jon Hopkins sample in the album’s intro.

Contribution: It adds to the discussion by focusing on a particular detail that Mainlining did not mention, providing a different angle on the album’s production value.

Response 3: “read this in Christian Bale's voice”

Humor and Context: This response seems to be a humorous suggestion to read Mainlining’s post in the voice of actor Christian Bale, known for his intense or dramatic delivery.

Implication: It reflects a playful or mocking attitude towards the detailed analysis, possibly suggesting that the respondent finds the post’s tone or content dramatic or over-the-top.

Detailed Analysis

Mainlining’s Perspective:

Expertise and Insight: Mainlining’s detailed breakdown of Coldplay’s album production shows a sophisticated understanding of both music production and the interplay between artists and producers. This reflects an appreciation for the artistic and technical aspects of music.

Connection to Broader Influences: By linking Coldplay’s album to The Velvet Underground and John Cale, Mainlining situates the discussion within a broader historical and stylistic context, indicating a deep engagement with music history and influence.

Responses:

Diverse Reactions: The responses vary widely in tone and content, ranging from dismissive criticism to specific praise and humor.

Response 1 dismisses the intellectual analysis, possibly reflecting a preference for less nuanced or more straightforward opinions.

Response 2 adds a new element to the discussion, showing engagement with specific details of the album’s production.

Response 3 introduces humor, reflecting a reaction to the post’s tone or content rather than its substance.

Overall Interaction:

Contrast in Engagement: The range of responses highlights different attitudes towards the analysis of music. While Mainlining’s post is thoughtful and detailed, the responses show a spectrum from derision to additional commentary, reflecting varying levels of engagement and appreciation for in-depth analysis.

In summary, Mainlining’s post provides a detailed and insightful analysis of Viva La Vida, attributing its quality to Brian Eno’s production and exploring its conceptual influences. The responses reflect a range of reactions, from dismissive and humorous to specific and constructive, showcasing the diversity of opinions and engagement with the topic.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5124628&forum_id=2...id#48046334)