shitlibs every year: "did we REALLY have to bomb the Japs?"
| Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | green double fault mental disorder | 08/06/15 | | abusive sneaky criminal | 08/06/15 | | sick awkward codepig | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | Lemon incel prole | 08/06/15 | | Gold Meetinghouse Bbw | 08/06/15 | | Startling dingle berry menage | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | nubile parlour | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Razzle international law enforcement agency | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Poppy Judgmental University | 08/06/15 | | Lemon incel prole | 08/06/15 | | Razzle international law enforcement agency | 08/06/15 | | nubile parlour | 08/06/15 | | Maize passionate therapy private investor | 08/06/15 | | sexy elastic band | 08/06/15 | | irradiated den hissy fit | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | yellow mad-dog skullcap | 08/06/15 | | Transparent gaping | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | Lemon incel prole | 08/06/15 | | irradiated den hissy fit | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Transparent gaping | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | Transparent gaping | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | Lemon incel prole | 08/06/15 | | Lemon incel prole | 08/06/15 | | vibrant pozpig range | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | irradiated den hissy fit | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | Galvanic puce newt volcanic crater | 08/06/15 | | Underhanded exhilarant gaming laptop | 08/06/15 | | Swollen Wild Genital Piercing Property | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | Bearded Water Buffalo | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | Racy Lodge Crotch | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | Chest-beating lascivious national | 08/07/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | razzle-dazzle olive nursing home messiness | 08/06/15 | | hot brunch | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma | 08/06/15 | | Iridescent medicated church building | 08/06/15 | | Crimson Curious Pit | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | Crawly orange round eye reading party | 08/06/15 | | Crawly orange round eye reading party | 08/06/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | Tripping exciting resort | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Galvanic puce newt volcanic crater | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Crawly orange round eye reading party | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Jade Athletic Conference Abode | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Jade Athletic Conference Abode | 08/06/15 | | Mint ratface | 08/06/15 | | vibrant pozpig range | 08/06/15 | | Crawly orange round eye reading party | 08/06/15 | | Confused fluffy stage | 08/06/15 | | vibrant pozpig range | 08/06/15 | | Nudist jet set | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Crawly orange round eye reading party | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | charismatic people who are hurt kitchen | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | vibrant pozpig range | 08/06/15 | | Transparent gaping | 08/07/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | Nudist jet set | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | sapphire depressive | 08/09/15 | | honey-headed plaza | 08/06/15 | | Garnet yarmulke institution | 08/06/15 | | green double fault mental disorder | 08/06/15 | | vibrant pozpig range | 08/06/15 | | Iridescent medicated church building | 08/06/15 | | pink center becky | 08/06/15 | | slippery aphrodisiac cruise ship | 08/06/15 | | Tripping exciting resort | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | slippery aphrodisiac cruise ship | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | slippery aphrodisiac cruise ship | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | Nudist jet set | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Transparent gaping | 08/07/15 | | Histrionic Ungodly Church | 08/06/15 | | fishy 180 striped hyena casino | 08/06/15 | | sexy elastic band | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | sexy elastic band | 08/06/15 | | Bateful Bronze Locale | 08/06/15 | | sexy elastic band | 08/06/15 | | fishy 180 striped hyena casino | 08/06/15 | | Citrine fragrant location black woman | 08/06/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | avocado swashbuckling factory reset button | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Jade Athletic Conference Abode | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Jade Athletic Conference Abode | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Jade Athletic Conference Abode | 08/06/15 | | irradiated den hissy fit | 08/06/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | green double fault mental disorder | 08/06/15 | | avocado swashbuckling factory reset button | 08/06/15 | | mustard quadroon | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | Crimson Curious Pit | 08/06/15 | | hateful duck-like site puppy | 08/06/15 | | dun concupiscible orchestra pit tank | 08/06/15 | | Brindle Aromatic Kitty Cat | 08/06/15 | | sapphire depressive | 08/09/15 | | charismatic people who are hurt kitchen | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | floppy coffee pot | 08/06/15 | | Scarlet turdskin | 08/06/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action | 08/06/15 | | stirring elite main people | 08/06/15 | | Magenta wonderful address | 08/06/15 | | Dark gas station | 08/06/15 | | Magenta wonderful address | 08/06/15 | | Spectacular anal cuck masturbator | 08/06/15 | | aqua odious psychic | 08/06/15 | | Scarlet turdskin | 08/06/15 | | Scarlet turdskin | 08/06/15 | | big point fanboi | 08/06/15 | | Scarlet turdskin | 08/06/15 | | Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor | 08/06/15 | | Cheese-eating hall stock car | 08/06/15 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: August 6th, 2015 8:57 AM Author: big point fanboi
I oppose the bombings on moral grounds. It's never acceptable to intentionally butcher civilians.
Here's an article that helped change my mind on the issue:
http://www.andrewcusack.com/2010/debating-hiroshima/
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28489825) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 1:33 PM Author: Lemon incel prole
There's no such thing as a "just war".
All wars are fucking bullshit by their very nature:
Human killing Human
There is no logic behind it, but it is the most basic human institution there is.
All Wars are fucked up.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491213) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 10:00 AM Author: nubile parlour
me: no it isnt
u: yes it is
me: no it isnt
welcome 2 the rabbit hole of human rights
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490009) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 11:26 AM Author: Impressive Slap-happy Dilemma
Sorry, I can't buy this. What you're saying may be correct in an academic sort of way. But we have to live in the real world. WWI was the first war in which full industrialization was used to kill armies. During WWII, that industrialization was used to kill entire populations. We were fighting pure evil ... there's no other way to categorize nazi germany and imperial japan. Not saying that the allies were saints at the time; but by comparison, the atheist states of germany, ussr, and japan were quite willing to slaughter anyone population who was inconvenient to them. And all three nations rose from the mistakes of WWI.
So the allies could have stopped and tried a more enlightened war and peace, just like the armistice of November 1918. Fortunately for us now, they did not. FDR & Churchill saw the mistakes of the past and pushed to really win this war, doing whatever was necessary to end it. And we had to strength and moral fortitude to do what was indeed necessary ... not only during the war, but in the decades afterwards, keeping our troops on the ground to change germany and japan's entire culture.
It worked. No one can realistically picture either Germany or Japan starting a war today. Instead of wars breaking out every decade or two in Europe and East Asia, wars of conquest and aggression, there has largely been peace.
tl;dr You're Wilson.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490419) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:08 PM Author: arousing misanthropic stead affirmative action
Except I'm not calling for wanton butchering of innocent people. I'm calling for dropping an A-bomb on a city that had a high concentration of military facilities, military factories, and, in particular, the the headquarters of Field Marshal Shunroku Hata's Second General Army, which commanded the defense of all of southern Japan.
Also, many of these "innocents" worked in factories that built airplanes, tanks, guns, bayonets, for soldiers that massacred tens of millions of actual innocent in SE Asia. These "innocents" supported a government that invaded other countries for its own gain, raped and massacred tens of millions of people, and preached racial superiority of the Japanese.
These "innocents" were training to fight US soldiers to the death once they landed on Japanese shores. Innocent is not something I'd assign to many of the victims of the A-bomb.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490700) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:13 PM Author: big point fanboi
(guy classifying a farmer as a military target because he grows food that people can eat)
(guy who thinks children under age 5 can be trained to do much of anything)
(guy who thinks people who can't vote and live in a military dictatorship can meaningfully "support" or "oppose" their government)
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490735) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 1:31 PM Author: Lemon incel prole
Hey Jackass, General Tecumseh ALPHA AS FUCK Sherman wasn't dealing with a Gov't that encouraged the civilian population to engage in TOTAL WAR.
Your average Southerner was dumb, poor, and impoverished due to the crumbling Southern War effort, they would not have put up a fight against Union forces.
The Japanese was ACTIVELY involved in training civilians to use any weapon possible to repeal an invasion by Allied forces.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491204) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 9:16 AM Author: Bateful Bronze Locale
(jap)
why the fuck should even one more US troop die for a war that they started?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28489874)
|
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 10:45 AM Author: Galvanic puce newt volcanic crater
Even if you do assume jap and Americans lies hold equal value:
We would have kept bombing the fuck out of them with conventional weapons for months during an invasion build up
If you think we shouldn't have bombed on civilians at all, then the japs would have fought even longer.
They had plans to turn all civilians into combatants or to mass suicide. They would have made women and children do human kamakazi attacks. After a few of your buddies get killed by some twat with a grenade, U.S. Soilders would just start shooting them.
There is no way a full scale invasion of Japan doesn't at least kill over 200k civilians. Plus we'd still bomb cities anyway.
Bombs saved lives.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490179) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 2:31 PM Author: Underhanded exhilarant gaming laptop
I've always been somewhat swayed by the fact that they still didn't surrender after the first one.
Im not a scholar but it doesn't seem clear that the emperor was even in control by that point, and rather the military was just bullshitting him and doing what they wanted. Some believe the Japanese wanted to surrender after the first bomb, but I don't buy it.
They seemed perfectly willing to let their cities be nuked and/or firebombed completely and/or all their citizens die somehow, up until they believed they had no chance of winning without being completely destroyed and radiated in the process.
Seems reasonable to go all out and end it ASAP with the bombs.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491582) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:41 PM Author: charismatic people who are hurt kitchen
I mean, after Hiroshima and before Nagasaki we DID drop leaflets saying pretty much that. And even so, the Japanese high command sat around flicking their critpeens.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/primary-resources/truman-leaflets/
Leaflets dropped on cities in Japan warning civilians about the atomic bomb, dropped c. August 6, 1945
TO THE JAPANESE PEOPLE:
America asks that you take immediate heed of what we say on this leaflet.
We are in possession of the most destructive explosive ever devised by man. A single one of our newly developed atomic bombs is actually the equivalent in explosive power to what 2000 of our giant B-29s can carry on a single mission. This awful fact is one for you to ponder and we solemnly assure you it is grimly accurate.
We have just begun to use this weapon against your homeland. If you still have any doubt, make inquiry as to what happened to Hiroshima when just one atomic bomb fell on that city.
Before using this bomb to destroy every resource of the military by which they are prolonging this useless war, we ask that you now petition the Emperor to end the war. Our president has outlined for you the thirteen consequences of an honorable surrender. We urge that you accept these consequences and begin the work of building a new, better and peace-loving Japan.
You should take steps now to cease military resistance. Otherwise, we shall resolutely employ this bomb and all our other superior weapons to promptly and forcefully end the war.
EVACUATE YOUR CITIES.
ATTENTION JAPANESE PEOPLE. EVACUATE YOUR CITIES.
Because your military leaders have rejected the thirteen part surrender declaration, two momentous events have occurred in the last few days.
The Soviet Union, because of this rejection on the part of the military has notified your Ambassador Sato that it has declared war on your nation. Thus, all powerful countries of the world are now at war with you.
Also, because of your leaders' refusal to accept the surrender declaration that would enable Japan to honorably end this useless war, we have employed our atomic bomb.
A single one of our newly developed atomic bombs is actually the equivalent in explosive power to what 2000 of our giant B-29s could have carried on a single mission. Radio Tokyo has told you that with the first use of this weapon of total destruction, Hiroshima was virtually destroyed.
Before we use this bomb again and again to destroy every resource of the military by which they are prolonging this useless war, petition the emperor now to end the war. Our president has outlined for you the thirteen consequences of an honorable surrender. We urge that you accept these consequences and begin the work of building a new, better, and peace-loving Japan.
Act at once or we shall resolutely employ this bomb and all our other superior weapons to promptly and forcefully end the war.
EVACUATE YOUR CITIES.
Source: Harry S. Truman Library, Miscellaneous historical document file, no. 258.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490936)
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 9:07 AM Author: Nudist jet set
It was a lib president who dropped the bomb too, before libs became SHITlibs. The transformation of the left from people like Truman to people who lisp "NOT OKAY" is tragic.
As for atomic bombs, they saved hundreds of thousands of lives in WW2 and have saved more lives in the 70 years since by serving as a powerful deterrent. Thank god for the atom bomb indeed.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28489846) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 10:10 AM Author: Garnet yarmulke institution
Son, we live in a world that has Japs. And those Japs have to be bombed by atom bombs. Who's gonna do it? You? You, Lt. Shitlib? I have a greater responsibility than you can possibly fathom. You weep for gooks and you curse whitey. You have that luxury. You have the luxury of not knowing what I know: that dropping the atom bombs, while tragic, probably saved lives. And the atom bombs, while grotesque and incomprehensible to you, saves lives...You don't want the truth. Because deep down, in places you don't talk about at parties, you wanted to drop those bombs. You needed to drop those bombs.
We use words like PROBLWMATIC, EQUALITY, and NOT OKAY ...we use these words as the backbone to a life spent riding faggot AIDS cock. You use 'em as a punchline. I have neither the time nor the inclination to explain myself to a man who penetrates and pounds the very faghole I provide, then questions the manner in which I provide it! I'd rather you just said thank you, atom bombs, and went on your way. Otherwise, I suggest you put on a dress and chop off your dick. Either way, I don't give a damn what you think you're entitled to!
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490052) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 10:47 AM Author: big point fanboi
No, I mean people like:
-Fulton Sheen, a premier Catholic bishop in the U.S.
-David Lawrence, conservative owner of U.S. News
-The conservative editorial staff of the Chicago Tribune
-The editors at National Review, who condemned Truman's decision to use the bomb in the 50s
-Conservative writer George Schuyler
-Catholic philosopher Elizabeth Anscombe
-Catholic World editor Fr. James Gillis
-Anglican bishop George Bell
-Ex-leftist and major conservative thinker Richard Weaver
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490193) |
Date: August 6th, 2015 10:46 AM Author: sexy elastic band
did US know what would happen? it seems like hiroshima is justified but nagaski might not be.
did y'all read the john hershey new yorker stories?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490185) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:04 PM Author: Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor
This is actually getting kind of fun. You are aware that the Union Army deliberately shelled civilians in Charleston with the "Swamp Angel" battery on Morris Island. They didn't cause much damage but they were firing incendiary devices intended to cause fires and civilian casualties - that it occurred on a much smaller scale was only a result of a lack of technology. However, at the time, it was a technological marvel, as it was both the first long range bombardment of an area using mathematics to aim cannon and the first area bombardment of a civilian population (they used St. Phillips church steeple as aiming point).
That is in addition to the Burning of Bluffton early in teh war (1862?) to where the Union Army intentionally attacked a small civilian village after the fall of Fort Wagner. There was no real military target and the purpose was to punish the civilian population and destroy property.
But go on, I'm enjoying your educating me about history.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490676) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:14 PM Author: Vivacious walnut fortuitous meteor
Bluffton burning - odd decision by local commander.
Targeting of civilians in Charleston (a major campaign of the civil war) - dudarama, that shit happened.
Sherman, the humanitarian. Run with this some more. Motherfucker burnt Atlanta and Columbia to the ground.
How old are you?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490746) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:41 PM Author: Jade Athletic Conference Abode
"You cannot qualify war in harsher terms than I will. War is cruelty, and you cannot refine it; and those who brought war into our country deserve all the curses and maledictions a people can pour out."
-General William Tecumseh Sherman
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490943)
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 11:09 AM Author: green double fault mental disorder
I just responded thusly on FB to a Japanese American dude who posted something to this effect regarding the use of the atom bomb:
Uh, if you fuck with the bull, you get the horns. The only people to blame for the atom bomb being dropped on Hiroshima are the Japanese. Period. End of story.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490319) |
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:39 PM Author: charismatic people who are hurt kitchen
CharlesXII brother you are getting unhinged itt. you know full well that the atomic bombs weren't used to "maximize civilian deaths." Hiroshima and Nagasaki were mid-size cities chosen for their industrial and military importance. You're being a disingenuous fag for arguing otherwise and doing so in a way that is unbecoming of ur IQ and ur historical and political knowledge.
The Potsdam Declaration in late July laid out the terms for Japan's surrender, lest it face "prompt and utter destruction." Japan told us to STFU. We bombed Hiroshima (then dropped a bunch of leaflets and Truman gave speeches saying there was more coming and telling Japanese civilians to evacuate their cities). Still the Japanese leadership said "ndb, they probably don't have any more and couldn't invade for a while anyway." It was only after Nagasaki AND the Soviets declaring war and moving into Manchuria that Hirohito and Tojo decided to surrender, and EVEN THEN, tons of military officers went apeshit and tried to storm the palace to prevent Hirohito from broadcasting the surrender.
Up above you referenced Sherman's march to the sea. As you well know, Sherman didn't HAVE to go house to house killing civilians and getting roadside bombed, because Lee set the tone for how the South waged war, and as horrible as it was, when the decision came as to how they would proceed at the end -- surrender or dissipate into the woods and launch guerrilla attacks -- Lee recognized there is more dishonor in civilians being bands of robbers than there is in laying down ur arms when beaten. The Japanese believed differently.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490918) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 12:49 PM Author: big point fanboi
1. Other than Kyoto (which was avoided for political reasons) Hiroshima was the largest city that hadn't been substantially bombed during the war, so it pretty much WAS the city that would probably see the most casualties in an attack. Its military significance was not that great, which helps to explain the lack of bombing despite its size.
Still, I'll retract my claim that the U.S. was literally "maximizing" civilian casualties, though I do believe they were callous about them and ignored viable alternatives that could have lowered the body count.
Keep in mind that as far as strat bombing goes in general, killing lots of civilians WAS a goal.
2. The Potsdam Declaration and leaflet shit are disingenuous hack arguments and hardly worth addressing. Decisions by leadership don't justify the massacre of innocents; nor does the inability of the powerless to act.
3. Your Civil War argument doesn't make any sense bro. Lee did not fight in the Western theater, and you're also creating a fictitous, super-noble Southern approach to war. In fact, out west the South actually DID have murderous guerrilla fighters, but that still didn't lead to the wholesale extermination of towns and cities.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28490984) |
|
Date: August 6th, 2015 2:06 PM Author: floppy coffee pot
At the time of its bombing, Hiroshima was a city of both industrial and military significance. A number of military units were located nearby, the most important of which was the headquarters of Field Marshal Shunroku Hata's Second General Army, which commanded the defense of all of southern Japan,[104] and was located in Hiroshima Castle. Hata's command consisted of some 400,000 men, most of whom were on Kyushu where an Allied invasion was correctly anticipated.[105] Also present in Hiroshima were the headquarters of the 59th Army, the 5th Division and the 224th Division, a recently formed mobile unit.[106] The city was defended by five batteries of 7-and-8-centimeter (2.8 and 3.1 in) anti-aircraft guns of the 3rd Anti-Aircraft Division, including units from the 121st and 122nd Anti-Aircraft Regiments and the 22nd and 45th Separate Anti-Aircraft Battalions. In total, over 40,000 military personnel were stationed in the city.[107]
Hiroshima was a minor supply and logistics base for the Japanese military, but it also had large stockpiles of military supplies.[108] The city was a communications center, a key port for shipping and an assembly area for troops.[73] It was also the second largest city in Japan after Kyoto that was still undamaged by air raids,[109] due to the fact that it lacked the aircraft manufacturing industry that was the XXI Bomber Command's priority target.
The goal wasn't to kill the most civilians. It was to allow for the biggest impact in order to convince Japan that they needed to accept the terms of surrender. The geography of Hiroshima was thought to allow for enhancement of the blast, and would create a wider amount of destruction (yes this would generally mean more casualties, but the important thing was to destroy as much of the city as possible with one blast, even if it was empty).
Hiroshima was described as "an important army depot and port of embarkation in the middle of an urban industrial area. It is a good radar target and it is such a size that a large part of the city could be extensively damaged. There are adjacent hills which are likely to produce a focusing effect which would considerably increase the blast damage. Due to rivers it is not a good incendiary target."[70]
The Target Committee stated that "It was agreed that psychological factors in the target selection were of great importance. Two aspects of this are (1) obtaining the greatest psychological effect against Japan and (2) making the initial use sufficiently spectacular for the importance of the weapon to be internationally recognized when publicity on it is released. Kyoto had the advantage of being an important center for military industry, as well an intellectual center and hence a population better able to appreciate the significance of the weapon. The Emperor's palace in Tokyo has a greater fame than any other target but is of least strategic value."[70]
The only reason they didn't warn civilians in advance (not that they would or could have listened) is that they were worried the Japanese would intercept the plane and be able to steal the weapon. It seems disingenuous to assume that the goal was mass casualties. Military heads even discussed allowing for a demonstration of the bomb's capabilities to try to convince Japan to surrender, but they saw nothing that would convince them to short of direct military use.
And even then, it still took a SECOND bombing AND Russia declaring war to convince them to stop. War is ugly and civilian casualties are tragic but unfortunately inevitable. Shitlibs act like someone said "ok, the bomb's ready, let's throw it on the biggest city they have!" The President and military leaders spent MONTHS carefully selecting targets, trying to come up with peaceful alternatives, and simultaneously planning a land invasion. They weighed all the options before them and selected what they thought would lead to the quickest end to the war with the least amount of casualties on BOTH sides. They didn't just say "fuck it, burn 'em all."
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491453) |
Date: August 6th, 2015 2:15 PM Author: Magenta wonderful address
There actually was a third alternative to bombing and invasion: an indefinite blockade. Japan was in no position to rebuild its forces without outside resources.
I'm sure shitlibs would tout this as the humane alternative, but it would've wrought mass starvation, doing much more harm to civilians than nukes.
Yes, nukes were the least evil of all options on the table
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491510) |
Date: August 6th, 2015 2:49 PM Author: Spectacular anal cuck masturbator
For various reasons I don't want to go into here, the "just war" argument given above doesn't sway me.
Someone I know recently argued that the Japanese were going to surrender anyway and that the primary purpose of the atomic bombs was to intimidate the USSR. If true, I probably would condemn the act as a senseless massacre. However, this does not appear to be the case. See this reddit comment by a professional historian, which I have copied below.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2zty7o/in_one_my_my_professors_lectures_he_mentioned/cpmtknh
TheGuineaPig21 14 points 4 months ago
Research from the 1990s has fundamentally changed the answer to this question, and using sources like Alperovitz or even Bernstein that are fairly out of vogue misrepresents the current historical consensus on the matter, in my opinion.
Prior to the decision to drop the bomb, some members of the Japanese political leadership were working behind the scenes to try to negotiate a conditional surrender whose terms did (in many ways) closely resemble the unconditional terms of peace that was later accepted.
This is true. There were individuals, particularly in the civilian government, who urged surrender. The Japanese ambassador to the Soviet Union is a prominent example. Likewise, the military establishment was dead set against it. One of the key impacts of recent research has been efforts to qualify the relative importance of each, and the conclusion has been that it was the military, and most importantly the six-person War Council, who ultimately had real control.
The War Council met on August 9th, 1945 to discuss suing for peace, in response to the bombing of Hiroshima and the attack by the Soviet Union. During the course of the meeting news was delivered that Nagasaki had likewise been destroyed by an atomic bomb. At the end of the meeting their opinion on surrender was the following:
all six rejected unconditional surrender
three supported surrender on the condition that the Emperor remain unaffected
three supported surrender on the further conditions that Japan try its own war criminals, conduct its own disarmament, and not be occupied
It's obvious to see how these terms were non-starters. And this was the situation after two atomic bombs and the Soviet attack. Tsuyoshi Hasegawa concluded in his work Racing the Enemy that “without the twin shocks of the atomic bombs and Soviet entry into the war, the Japanese would never have accepted surrender in August". This is accepted position among most publishing historians on this subject matter.
I have a ton of sources, but if you want to read about historiography there's a pair of articles by J. Samuel Walker from 1990 and 2005 that charts the historiography of the subject that give some insight into the way opinions have shifted. The former is called "The Decision to Use the Bomb: A Historiographical Update", and the latter there is a free link to here.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28491698) |
Date: August 6th, 2015 3:36 PM Author: Scarlet turdskin
Dan Carlin does a great job with this debate. He does a full recap of the history of carpet bombing of civilians, from Guernica to Hiroshima. His general conclusion is that, as far as human suffering goes, there is no significant difference between being A-bombed or fire-bombed or carpet-bombed otherwise for the people on the ground. USA is therefore morally no different than any of the other powers of WWII. Honestly, there's no point in debating this among amateurs when you can listen to the HH episode about it.
http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-42-blitz-logical-insanity/
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2955065&forum_id=2#28492136)
|
|
|