***MPM2017 ANNOUNCEMENT - RULE AND FORMAT CHANGES***
| zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | cerise shrine macaca | 12/08/21 | | Emerald school cafeteria juggernaut | 10/19/17 | | Hot area fanboi | 10/19/17 | | submissive indian lodge athletic conference | 10/19/17 | | light heady field | 10/19/17 | | seedy sex offender senate | 10/19/17 | | Appetizing site filthpig | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | aquamarine selfie milk | 10/19/17 | | hairraiser cruel-hearted doctorate pit | 10/19/17 | | light heady field | 10/19/17 | | soul-stirring embarrassed to the bone school | 10/19/17 | | aquamarine selfie milk | 10/19/17 | | seedy sex offender senate | 10/19/17 | | glassy hunting ground masturbator | 10/19/17 | | submissive indian lodge athletic conference | 10/19/17 | | aquamarine selfie milk | 10/19/17 | | glassy hunting ground masturbator | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | razzmatazz puce public bath | 10/19/17 | | Emerald school cafeteria juggernaut | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | free-loading den | 10/19/17 | | aquamarine selfie milk | 10/19/17 | | free-loading den | 10/19/17 | | Cordovan library | 10/19/17 | | aquamarine selfie milk | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | Cordovan library | 10/19/17 | | crawly sooty stag film | 10/19/17 | | chocolate big becky | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | Wild excitant lay | 10/19/17 | | light heady field | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | wonderful blood rage theater | 10/19/17 | | Emerald school cafeteria juggernaut | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Electric brethren philosopher-king | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | hairraiser cruel-hearted doctorate pit | 10/19/17 | | Vivacious Rehab Digit Ratio | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | startling exhilarant church building lettuce | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | stimulating well-lubricated stage | 10/19/17 | | Chartreuse business firm | 12/27/17 | | wonderful blood rage theater | 10/19/17 | | Vivacious Rehab Digit Ratio | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | rusted lascivious base pozpig | 10/19/17 | | stirring misunderstood abode ceo | 10/19/17 | | hairraiser cruel-hearted doctorate pit | 10/19/17 | | Electric brethren philosopher-king | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | Electric brethren philosopher-king | 10/19/17 | | wonderful blood rage theater | 10/19/17 | | Comical Chad Codepig | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | Plum fiercely-loyal market | 10/19/17 | | contagious sweet tailpipe | 10/19/17 | | Exciting geriatric parlor | 10/19/17 | | aromatic lavender corner jewess | 10/19/17 | | submissive indian lodge athletic conference | 10/19/17 | | Khaki spectacular crotch sound barrier | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | Khaki spectacular crotch sound barrier | 10/19/17 | | zippy odious home | 10/19/17 | | Khaki spectacular crotch sound barrier | 10/19/17 | | dark associate hissy fit | 10/19/17 | | Plum fiercely-loyal market | 10/20/17 | | self-absorbed meetinghouse | 10/19/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/19/17 | | Comical Chad Codepig | 10/20/17 | | aromatic lavender corner jewess | 10/19/17 | | Charismatic Cheese-eating Hall Double Fault | 10/19/17 | | glassy hunting ground masturbator | 10/19/17 | | Pungent arousing alpha | 10/19/17 | | aphrodisiac theater stage scourge upon the earth | 10/20/17 | | Fantasy-prone 180 Set Elastic Band | 10/20/17 | | free-loading den | 10/20/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/20/17 | | gay native black woman | 10/20/17 | | Racy Box Office | 10/20/17 | | gay native black woman | 10/20/17 | | submissive indian lodge athletic conference | 10/20/17 |
Poast new message in this thread
|
Date: October 19th, 2017 11:20 AM Author: free-loading den
A long needed crackdown on alts/vote rigging.
Low seeds for prior semifinalists ensures they will have to make it on merit.
Forced content creation should be entertaining.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34478707) |
Date: October 19th, 2017 11:12 AM Author: chocolate big becky
"-To mitigate spamming by pumo/quotemo alts, all round outcomes are subject to review and, in extreme cases, reversal."
Just limit voting to known unique posters.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34478641) |
Date: October 19th, 2017 1:17 PM Author: Vivacious Rehab Digit Ratio
The low-seeds-for-semifinalists actually has a good idea behind it, though is a questionable execution.
Last year more than a few great poasters who probably would have pwned in other sections of the draw got arbitrarily stuffed into evan39s section and got steamrolled either by evan or each other, while mediocre poasters went far in the weak sections.
The best thing would be to seed the fucking tournament accurately and even out talent across all the sections, but if that's impossible this may be the next best thing.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479525)
|
|
Date: October 19th, 2017 1:40 PM Author: dark associate hissy fit
? who says you have to drop out? i seeded myself in the first two MPMs, i got beat handily by better poasters, and that was that. when voting is open and notorious with well-defined voting criteria, no cheating is possible, because it's just counting, and anyone can apply the criteria and check the count. as i recall, i was corrected once or twice in my tabulation.
a whitelist of permitted sudo voters, providing a particular voting format, and giving a firm open and close time for voting pretty much solves every partiality issue.
the only cheating that can happen is when bullshit like the above is suggested.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479716) |
|
Date: October 19th, 2017 2:04 PM Author: dark associate hissy fit
not that hard.
all 128 contestants last year are automatically whitelisted, under their known monikers only. that's thread #1. that's more just informing people. no real solicitation of opinion required.
new poasters, added to 2017's MPM using the consensus of XO plebs (using the suggested tiers or whatever), are also whitelisted. that's thread #2--who should be in it this year?
by now you have a whitelist of 128 (last year's) + new contestants who can vote.
thread #3, to be posted at least a week or two before voting--petition here to be added to the voting whitelist. that way, old dogs who happen to be around but aren't competing anymore can go under their known monikers and ask to be included. new guys who aren't yet known enough for MPM but want to be included can be. and if it's just someone's alt, i'm sure autists will comment and say "not this guy, it's just WMTP." that will be, i think, pretty much the only time you have to exercise any judgment on the matter.
not that tough, no?
that's about it.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479962) |
|
Date: October 19th, 2017 1:38 PM Author: dark associate hissy fit
for seeding, people running MPM should just create a thread of known sudos and ask people to rate them as "great, good, or okay" or something.
or, perhaps to save work, the people running MPM should offer their list of 128 sudos and suggested tiers - great, good, or okay, roughly corresponding with seeds of 1-8, 9-16, and 17-32 or so - and solicit input from poasters about whether poasters are in the approximately correct tiers.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479698) |
|
Date: October 19th, 2017 1:44 PM Author: rusted lascivious base pozpig
i think poasters should nominate other poasters as has been custom but your second suggestion is cr
the process last year was to vote over who got the top four seeds in each bracket, as though the specific seeds were important, and then everyone else was just scrambled around. the specific seeds really don't matter even at the top, just the tiers.
whoever runs it should come up with a top tier of 16, second tier of 16, third tier of 32, and then fourth tier of 64 (or two more tiers of 32). publish the tiers, people critique them, and they're adjusted as needed. seeds are then assigned based on those tiers.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479758) |
Date: October 19th, 2017 1:26 PM Author: rusted lascivious base pozpig
the low seeding of top posters idea is actually extremely dumb
the issue with seeding last year was that good seeding was extremely arbitrary, so in some brackets you had two very good posters matched up in the early rounds knocking each other out while mediocre posters cruised through for a few rounds in other brackets
if you're replacing the top posters with "next-best" posters at top seeds then you're just institutionalizing this problem. good posters be matched up against each other early and will knock each other out while the mediocre posters ranked in between them will coast through for a while
seeding should be standard. top posters at top spots, lower posters beneath them. worse posters exit earlier and top posters still inevitably face each other once the field is narrowed so nobody is getting a "free pass" just by being seeded at the top. people stick around for as long as they should.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3768569&forum_id=2#34479588) |
|
|