Poll: is Aaron Judge the greatest baseball player of all time?
| Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/26/24 | | Electric karate turdskin | 08/27/24 | | mauve twisted shrine | 08/26/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/26/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/26/24 | | arrogant overrated stag film trust fund | 08/27/24 | | charcoal vivacious therapy parlor | 08/26/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/26/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/26/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/26/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | cerebral peach nowag | 08/27/24 | | Autistic laser beams area | 08/27/24 | | Disgusting painfully honest piazza | 08/27/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/26/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/26/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/26/24 | | Cruel-hearted idiot tanning salon | 08/26/24 | | Buff swashbuckling space | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | tripping half-breed | 08/26/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/26/24 | | appetizing burgundy mad cow disease gaming laptop | 08/27/24 | | Contagious soggy temple | 08/26/24 | | Curious doctorate | 08/26/24 | | naked confused newt messiness | 08/26/24 | | Disgusting painfully honest piazza | 08/26/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/26/24 | | azure antidepressant drug kitty | 08/26/24 | | Disgusting painfully honest piazza | 08/27/24 | | azure antidepressant drug kitty | 08/27/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | arrogant overrated stag film trust fund | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | dull private investor theater | 08/27/24 | | bronze fantasy-prone menage | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | coyote ugly tp | 09/19/24 | | Cream Pit French Chef | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Mind-boggling dilemma | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | Razzle-dazzle Honey-headed Base | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | coiffed reading party university | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | coiffed reading party university | 08/27/24 | | duck-like infuriating principal's office ratface | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | hyperactive famous landscape painting meetinghouse | 08/27/24 | | duck-like infuriating principal's office ratface | 08/27/24 | | Buff swashbuckling space | 08/27/24 | | Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat | 08/27/24 | | wonderful friendly grandma corn cake | 08/27/24 | | A Technologically Advanced Pontiac Firebird | 09/19/24 | | A Technologically Advanced Pontiac Firebird | 09/20/24 | | Otto Skorzeny | 09/20/24 | | snoot | 09/20/24 | | A Technologically Advanced Pontiac Firebird | 09/20/24 | | Post nut horror | 09/20/24 |
Poast new message in this thread
|
Date: August 27th, 2024 8:58 AM Author: Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat
Ok, I'm going to try to educate you here. I say try because you come off as insanely stupid with your "a rod" and "Barry bonds" arguments.
I'll concede that the season isn't over yet, but Judge is on pace to hit >60 her with a 1.200 ops.
How many seasons did your 2 homies do that? Oh yeah, none.
I'll accept my apology now. Tyia.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48013288) |
|
Date: August 27th, 2024 9:05 AM Author: Mind-boggling dilemma
"I'll concede that the season isn't over yet, but Judge is on pace to hit >60 her with a 1.200 ops.
How many seasons did your 2 homies do that? Oh yeah, none."
Barry Bonds had 3 seasons with an OPS above 1.379, and hit 73 HR in one of them.
As for A Rod and Mike Trout, we're talking about aggregate performance over a career vs peak performance in a given season. Totally admit the season Judge is putting up is unbelievable
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48013315) |
Date: August 26th, 2024 10:36 PM Author: Cream Pit French Chef
he's not even greater than Mike Trout
he's a phenom, but best ever isn't even good flame/bait
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48012558) |
Date: August 26th, 2024 11:44 PM Author: Disgusting painfully honest piazza
2017: legit shot at MVP although only a Yankees fan or Astros-hater would say he was robbed when Altuve won
2018-2020: injury-plagued to where he was not even in the conversation for best current baseball player
2021: great year but Ohtani had a better year at the plate while also pitching at a top level which is insane if you look at what happens when any other athlete attempts the crossover
2022: obviously a monster year, performing at a level that if sustained would put him on the short list
2023: hurt again
2024: back to 2022 form
So 4 big years and now he's 32. Even comparing to other modern players, he would need a lot more good years to pass ARod and Bonds and I'd lay odds against it happening. And if we're talking about greatest baseball player of all time in a hypothetical alternative reality where MLB always had clear rules on PEDs and a flawless testing program, I don't know how to adjust historic performances or whether current guys are on something that flies under the radar but would be banned in a perfect world.
And if throw out the best players of the period that most of us remember, then the competition is Ruth, Gehrig, Mays, Williams, etc. In making these comparisons it's simply not interesting to observe that modern players with better nutrition, training, competition and selection mechanisms are physically stronger than dudes from 100 years ago. You measure actual performance vs. the actual competition as it existed in each player's time, because any other debate about non-overlapping players is mere speculation. If Judge had the durability to bang out 2000 games in a row his per-game production is sufficient to put him near the top, but he doesn't, and baseball greatness is usually measured by career performance rather than per-game performance.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48012740) |
|
Date: August 26th, 2024 11:55 PM Author: azure antidepressant drug kitty
great poast
>baseball greatness is usually measured by career performance rather than per-game performance.
for pitchers, is this a little different? koufax, pedro and halliday come to mind as guys who had extrmely high peaks but didnt exactly have longevity
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48012749) |
|
Date: August 27th, 2024 1:10 AM Author: Disgusting painfully honest piazza
I suppose so, because pitchers have more injuries and shorter careers. They've also sometimes been more likely to go through long college/minors/bullpen apprenticeships whereas top hitters tend to progress quickly.
Koufax is a special case in a bunch of ways (Brooklyn Jewish guy playing for NY/LA in the postwar period, so it would literally be impossible for someone to attract more media attention and boomer nostalgia; plus he really was exceptionally good).
Pedro and Halladay had normal declines for pitchers in their mid-30s who had carried big workloads and had some bad luck. Ideally they would have squeezed out a few more good years, and longevity/quality volume is a positive point for a few peers such as Johnson, Clemens, Maddux. I loved both Pedro and Halladay in their top years, but realistically they are not #1 looking at career performance.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48012843)
|
|
Date: August 27th, 2024 10:00 AM Author: Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat
really going out on a limb saying it's better to give a 10 year contract to a 25 year old than a 32 year old.
def need to perform a deep statistical analysis to reach this conclusion.
your new nickname is "Mr. Baseball".
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48013495) |
|
Date: August 27th, 2024 10:08 AM Author: Vibrant Talking Kitty Cat
the Ohtani argument is hilarious.
it used to be "hes a very good hitter AND also a very good pitcher. that combination makes him the best even if he's not the best at any 1 thing."
Now he's a DH and the same people are like "he's still a very good hitter AND he steals bases!"
JFC. These people would toss their own mothers down a flight of stairs if it would discredit aaron judge.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5583766&forum_id=2\u0026mark_id=5304212",#48013526) |
|
|