That's bullshit. No one is seriously arguing to harm people for a thought crime (wanting a better life)
It's the actual physical manifestation of crime (illegal entry, typically followed by displacement of legal workers, legal would-be renters, etc. and the attendant harms artificial supply and demand create for the rest of us) that we want to punish
Most of us realize how stupid it is to decriminalize shoplifting and the predictable ravages it would have on places like San Francisco that did so. It doesn't matter for the rest of society that the thieves "just wanted a better life," they were still affected by closing stores, higher prices, and loss of convenience, not to mention the surge in others copying the brazen theft when it was clear people could and were getting away with it in blatant fashion
It's really a pretty simple phenomenon if you put aside the propaganda and allow yourself to think plainly and logically about it