Date: November 17th, 2004 11:50 PM Author: sable stead place of business
Actually, I didn't bother to read the article. I don't care much about Boalt, and I care even less about some belligerent blacks with imaginary grievances. HTH.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:01 AM Author: Greedy private investor
I'm not toning down anything you racist asshole. I've read too many of your annoying posts and I'm fed up with your bullshit. Keep coming up with excuses about missing the fact that this protest was not a *black law student* protest. RAM, nice one!
"It's no secret that Boalt is letting in underqualified minorities with low scores." -- Who gives a flying fuck? Go cry about it in your pillow tonight.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:08 AM Author: tan stirring cuckold
That is the most ridiculous argument I have ever heard. Even if it were true that blacks have it better in this country than elsewhere, that is still no reason why they should not speak out if they feel they are being mistreated. What's sad is that I'm not even defending these people, I'm just pointing out the logical inconsistencies in just about every one of your posts.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:11 AM Author: Greedy private investor
He's just a racist asshole. If you read most of his threads, he's either bitching about liberals, the war, gays or minorities. I'm done messing with this fool. BTW, I like your moniker.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:13 AM Author: tan stirring cuckold
That's true. At first, I thought he could be reasoned with, but now I realize his best retorts are "go eat some watermelon" and "your relatives live in Africa". Sad, actually.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:20 AM Author: tan stirring cuckold
Not that it's any of your business, but I have more distant relatives in Europe than I do in Africa. The point is that none of this is relevant to our discussion, and the fact that someone has relatives in Africa surely should not be used as an insult.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:32 AM Author: sable stead place of business
I'm aware that you're half white. I even saw your photograph. Your skin is lighter than that of some white people.
Mentioning that you have sixth cousins in Africa was not an insult. I merely pointed out that your life is better than theirs as a direct consequence of slavery. Your ancestors were brought here and theirs weren't. You get all the benefits of America and they have a difficult life.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:10 AM Author: Greedy private investor
HAHAHA, you have no idea what the hell you're talking about. I have no regrets about my school and I will be happy graduating from law school with no debt because it makes it easier to go back to my other career if I so choose.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:05 AM Author: Zombie-like ape
Do you think someone who is anti-AA is racist? (Not saying that anythign you've said has necessarily given me that impression-- I'm just curious about your position).
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:15 AM Author: Greedy private investor
No, I don't think anti-AA people are racist. I do think AA should be based on economic status because even then, many of the really deserving minorities would qualify. I can understand the position of those who are anti-AA.
EDIT: I do think AC is racist, at least on this board. He's always making crude remarks about minorities, gays, liberals, etc.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:57 AM Author: costumed cocky ticket booth national security agency
please specify which AC you're talking about if you ever talk about this guy in another thread and it's not readily apparent to any lurkers which AC you're referring to.
Date: November 17th, 2004 11:55 PM Author: Zombie-like ape
Protests like this, for some reason, shift me from being slightly in favor of AA to being against it. "Imaginary grievances" indeed, or, more accurately, misguided grievances.
Date: November 17th, 2004 11:56 PM Author: tan stirring cuckold
The point is that it is extremely presumptuous of him to call these grievances "imaginary" without reading the damn article. Are you going to deny this?
Date: November 17th, 2004 11:57 PM Author: brass ceo space
I don't understand this one personally. It's not like Berkeley wouldn't want more black rep. on campus. And yes, "misguided grievance" is more accurate.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:08 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
This is correct. The administration has gone above and beyond trying to get more blacks on campus, but the voters passed Prop 209. What can you do? It's not the school's fault, so these protesters should be changing the object of their displeasure.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:04 AM Author: Disturbing Shaky Stag Film Party Of The First Part
I read the "article," their reason's stupid. They had a meeting about it tonight, so it's not like they were being ignored before they planned this protest. And having a meeting is about as far as you can get from "being silenced."
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:10 AM Author: frum lascivious liquid oxygen church building
the one to the right has a kinda busted face but i think that might be because of the hankerchief pushing against her face. they have great bodies and really nice skin tone.
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:45 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
Correct.
They see the University as a weaker link. Easier to conquer an institution than a state. Plus, it is in UC's charter to represent California demographics. UC's in a fucked-either-way position on this one.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:01 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
This protest was more about undergraduate admissions than graduate.
What I love is that there seems to be virtually no activism to get K-12 educational levels up for a lot of these inner city kids. All the activists want is a free ride to college, it seems, without putting in the hard work.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:05 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
Yeah, I saw them today. A black female admissions officer and I chatted over lunch as we watched the protest. Basically, she said that there is only so much the admissions office can do before breaking state law. She said it plainly: in the post-AA era you simply have to have the numbers and the ECs, or you will not compete.
While I disagree with the demands of the BRRC and BAMN, I think that the protest was a powerful statement of the appalingly low minority representation at Berkeley. It wouldn't be surprising if 10% of the black undergraduate population were in that picture...and this is a school of 24000 undergrads.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:12 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
BAMN is outright ridiculous. They're so militant that everyone considers them a joke.
That being said, the problem isn't with black admit rates--it is largely with black yield. Many of the blacks that Berkeley admits are offered pretty good packages at elite privates.
I say: keep going with a numbers based admissions process, drive test scores up, etc. Everyone--URM or not--is a prestige whore. If you want to get kids to come to Berkeley, keep raising admissions standards for everyone.
By the way, that admissions officer wasn't named Marquesa, was she?
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:03 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
Yeah, Marquesa has a great spirit and energy.
I saw her at a recent event, though, and something she said shocked me. She told the students to include their ethnicity, what languages they speak, etc in their personal statements. That seems like outright flouting of Prop 209.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:54 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
(1) One of the privileges of going to university is exposure to persons of various backgrounds. These differences include but are not limited to racial ones; given the importance of racial in America, it is natural that racial differences are powerful indicators of diversity. If there are 2 black students for every 98 non-black students, there is a problem.
(2) In an ideal world, the distribution of qualifications necessary for admission to Berkeley would not correlate to ethnicity. Furthermore, the makeup of students applying to Berkeley would match the state ethnic makeup. Therefore, the ethnic makeup would mimic that of the state.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:15 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
Your implicit assumption is that I think meritocracy, or at the least, integrity in admissions standards, should take a backseat to diversity. I don't. Now reread my post.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:19 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
That's right. I believe that how hard someone has worked and their results should matter more in the admissions game than their race. Now reread my post.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:32 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
(1) If all you can get is 2% (and even then people don't think we belong here), then fine. But you should not just throw your hand up and say "Oh, well!"
There is a problem: it is a lack of representation. If you don't see that problem, then I don't know what to say. In order to fix the problem, you should attack the root of it. Misfunding of inner-city predominantly minority schools, and lack of training for both parents and teachers to guide these at-rick children.
(2) I never said that the state should mandate the results. It seems you are debating the arguments of the BRRC and BAMN and not my statements.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:42 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
"and even then people don't think we belong here"
Well given the widespread state of AA that isn't surprising. Though if you go to a school that doesn't practice AA then that isn't fair.
"There is a problem: it is a lack of representation. If you don't see that problem, then I don't know what to say."
I don't see the problem.
"Misfunding of inner-city predominantly minority schools, and lack of training for both parents and teachers to guide these at-rick children."
I agree with this, though at-risk children rarely end up going to elite schools even if everything goes well. That's just a fact. And the goals of programs to help at-risk youth are far more modest. Indeed, the URMs you see at elite universities more often than not come from backgrounds similar to white students: upper middle class and above parents who have encouraged and supported them since they were kids.
"I ever said that the state should mandate the results."
That would be the only way to achieve the results you want.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:48 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
That isn't the only way to achieve the result I want. In fact, I'd say that it goes against what I want. I am more interested in the slow grueling work of making the black mainstream more interested in academic excellence, or at the very least, swelling the ranks of the educated blacks who already are. The proper representation will naturally come then, without the need for any state mandate.
But then again, you see no problem with the representation at the moment, so this must be nonsense to you.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:55 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
And if you want to use your time, effort, and money to promote that cause there's nothing wrong with that. In fact, its admirable to help others succeed. My objections come when the goals of social engineering are promoted by the state at the expense of others.
Re (1): This is the worst justification for diversity I have ever seen. If you want exposure to people of various backgrounds there are a TRILLION other, better, venues to gain that desired exposure. DO not deprive deserving students of their seat in a class so you can get off on cosmopolitanism.
Jesus-fuckin-christ. This is the third or fourth time I've said it on this thread alone, so listen up folks: while I see the value of diversity (something many don't value to begin with), I DO NOT THINK IT SHOULD BE PRIORITIZED OVER ADMISSIONS INTEGRITY. Call me crazy, but, in the long run, diversity and admissions integrity are not mutually exclusive.
Also, on a tangent, who is "deserving" and who is not deserving when you have asians with 3.3s and 1100 going to the same school as Asians and blacks with 3.8s and 1500s?
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:26 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
Yeah, but trying to enforce rigid representation is ridiculous, especially at a top school. Merit should win out--and it has to a large extent, exemplified by the large number of Asians on campus.
That being said, I'd love to see more whites and blacks on campus.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:31 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
I never said that I support the demands of the BRRC or BAMN. I do not think some sort of forced quota is the correct solution, and I do agree that merit should win out. I still, however, think that blacks are underrpresented at Berkeley.
Date: November 18th, 2004 1:58 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
I wasn't saying that it didn't--was merely correcting you. In addition, an "underrepresentation" of 2.7% worries me far less than the 75th SAT percentile of African Americans being 70 points LOWER than the 25th for Chinese Americans.
Does it bother anyone that the Chinese American 25th is 70 points higher than the African American 75th? I really wonder why there aren't massive counterprotests going on at Berkeley by Chinese, Indian and Japanese American groups.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:08 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Exactly. I hate this rhetoric about "the difference being meaningless." What I care about is that qualified Asian American and White applicants are being rejected in favor of less qualified URM students. Whether the number is 5, 50 or 500 is irrelevant.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:10 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
Like I said, just coming from a PR perspective...
It's like kicking someone when their down. That, (1) the 67 black athletes, who make up the majority of the black class of 2008, were judged no differently from their white and asian athelete counterparts; (2) they basically be arguing for the end of blacks admitted outside of athletics; and (3) any change would not significantly affect the asian admittance rate.
Blacks are an oh so convenient scapegoat for plain ol' rejection. Whether or not you agree with AA or the BRRC, that is undeniable.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:18 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
"It's like kicking someone when their down."
That is if you accept that races are individual entities. If they're not, then you're simply rejecting individuals who don't meet standards. This seems fair to me.
"the 67 black athletes"
And on that note, if no white athletes could compete with them, too bad for them. I wouldn't insist that they take whites just to make the basketball game "colorful."
"they basically be arguing for the end of blacks admitted outside of athletics"
If that's the only way they can get on their merits then why is that bad?
"any change would not significantly affect the asian admittance rate"
As a percentile, perhaps, but it would matter a hell of a lot to the people who actually were accepted to those spots that opened up.
"Blacks are an oh so convenient scapegoat for plain ol' rejection."
If you mean to imply that I'm taking this personally somehow you're wrong. I had very good luck in the admissions game.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:26 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
The entire sencond paragraph was just showing how it would look bad from PR perspective. That said, the significant proportion of athletes who make up the black population may be dragging down the overall blacks' stats. Then there is no argument to be made for changing the black admit rate, as we have agreed, the athletes got in on merit (maybe not academic, but still), and the non-athlete blacks may be perfectly competitive.
I wasn't referring to you personally. I was just referring to the prevailing undercurrent of thought amongst particualrly the Asian community at Berkeley (which is to say, the school) that the blacks and AA are the reason their older sister or cousin or whatever didn't get in.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:36 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
"The entire sencond paragraph was just showing how it would look bad from merit perspective."
No, it wouldn't. Do you even know what merit means? We're talking about their ability to get in on their accomplishments and achievements. Using race boosts in admissions cannot by definition be good from a merit perspective.
"That said, the significant proportion of athletes who make up the black population may be draggin down the overall blacks stats. Then there is no argument to be made for changing the black admit rate, as we have agreed, the athletes got in on merit (maybe not academic, but still), and the non-athlete blacks may be perfectly competitive."
If that is the case then we don't have a problem. But I doubt that this is the whole story.
"I wasn't referring to you personally. I was just referring to the prevailing undercurrent of thought amongst particualrly the Asian community at Berkeley (which is to say, the school) that the blacks and AA are the reason their older sister or cousin or whatever didn't get in."
Its hard not to feel that way when they're getting rejected with a 1400+ SAT score when someone else got in with an 1150 just because of their skin color. Its human nature to resent such a system.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:53 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
No, I've never said or implied that we should accept this [rolls eyes] unfair system. What I am saying (which I have not said before) is that it is of my opinion that there no point at which people will think blacks will "deserve" to go here. In the wake of prop 209, the black admit rate and percentage of the incoming freshman clas droped precipitiously. You'd think then that people would say, "Oh, these must be the students who would've and did get in anyways without AA." Have they? I think not.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:57 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Perhaps if admissions officers didn't publicly try to flout Prop 209 and if they stopped admitting a greater proportion of URM students with lower numbers people would begin to think they were following the law.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:01 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
I actually agree with you here.
The administration has shown, since Prop 209, overarching concern for "diversity". Pre 209, it was much more about excellence.
I think Ward Connerly actually did more harm than good by passing 209, simply because the reaction by Cal has been so extreme. UCLA, in contrast, has taken a far more cool stance.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:00 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
" it is of my opinion that there no point at which people will think blacks will "deserve" to go here"
Its one thing if you can say "ah, well here are statistics that prove the naysayers wrong." But instead the statistics are solidly against you.
"In the wake of prop 209, the black admit rate and percentage of the incoming freshman clas droped precipitiously. You'd think then that people would say, "Oh, these must be the students who would've and did get in anyways without AA." Have they? I think not."
I think most people agree that there has been a significant improvement since the pre-prop 209 days. Honestly, while I think some fudging goes on in the UC system I think that nationally its clearly one of the better ones in regard to this issue. Afterall, you're right, with athletics factored in you're not really talking about cutting a significant number of black students. Maybe it would go from 2%-->1.7%. Not huge. This debate was merely philosophical from my standpoint.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:18 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
How, when, there are a significant number of Asian students who got by these low standards, are Asian students to do this without basically saying, "Admit fewer blacks now!"
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:37 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
And the fact is also that it would be more fair.
Furthermore, I think it would only be a PR nightmare to some liberal elitists. Most blacks wouldn't care (black culture isn't too centered on what happens in elite academia), and most whites and Asians would support this change in policy.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:48 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Correct. The term "significant" must be a relative term, relative that is to the total number of Asian American students. By your logic, even if the average Berkeley student meets 5 1200+ Asian American students for every 1 sub-1200 Asian American student, he or she still sees a "significant" group of low-SAT Asian Americans. Clearly, this makes no sense.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:00 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
What I'm saying is that blacks don't have a monopoly on low SAT scores. This is to counter someone's suggestion that the Asian groups (not just a group of high-scoring students) mobilize to demand higher standards, implying that this is in their favor. I am saying that the majority of changes would come in Asians replacing other low-scoring Asians and whites.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:00 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
Asians aren't ones to protest. However, there is a strong undercurrent among Asians of the types of feelings you are suggesting.
As for Berkeley, thank God for Asians. They can't be put into the oppressive white category, yet they kick ass academically, though many come from backgrounds more disadvantaged than blacks/Latinos.
The current average SAT score is about 1350. However, had the University not taken steps to curb the decline in URMs after 1998 (i.e. instituting comprehensive review), it is likely the average SAT would be 1400 or more. The 1998 numbers are the last before comprehensive review went into effect.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:13 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
We can argue mean vs. median, but the fact is that many schools use the mean when computing figures, so the mean remains a useful tool to calculate. In any event, Berkeley has no excuse for a 1330 average when it is rejecting over 1000 people with 1400+ every year in favor of 1000+ with sub-1300.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:13 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
I agree. Also note, however, that many schools use best combined, whereas Berkeley uses best single sitting. That alone accounts for a 30-40 point deficit.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:43 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
I have always noted the single sitting policy and agree it must be mentioned. However, no conclusive studies to my knowledge have been done on score differentials (especially those at Berkeley specifically), so I hesitate to throw out a figure like 30-40.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:48 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
It's an approximation, given a 25-75 split of 1210/1450.
Also, the SF Chronicle reported that Berkeley mean SAT score for this year's admit class was 1361. I would guess the mean enrolled SAT is in the 1320-1330 range.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:08 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
My guess is that there would be a very slight dip in the actual figure (27 people with 1300+ left in the summer and 23 with a sub-1300 left in the summer in 2003).
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:06 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Maybe if Berkeley had admitted the 301 [EDIT: Asian American] students with 1500+ it rejected last year, its average SAT score would be higher than the low 1300s.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:13 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
The solution is actually admitting more out of state applicants. That would make the student body stronger, and make the general experience better--less regional.
The Berkeley administration insists on adhering to public/state duty even though the state has fiscally abandoned the school. I don't fucking get it.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:36 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Berkeley's hands are tied:
1. In order to raise materially standards for admission to the lower division, the state colleges select first-time freshmen from the top one-third (33 per cent) and the University from the top one-eighth (12½ percent) of all graduates of California public high schools with … [g]raduates of private and out-of-state secondary schools to be held to equivalent levels. [pp. 73-74, A Master Plan for Higher Education in California, Sacramento, 1960]
If they deviated more than 2-3% from that 12.5% figure, politicians would have a field day and it would come to a grinding halt.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:59 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
This is irrelevant to the number of out of staters Berkeley could accept. While UC should select freshmen from the top eighth, many of these students go elsewhere. Plus, there are eight other campuses in the system.
As the flagship, I think Berkeley should be different, exercise its world class stature and name recognition and admit far more out of staters. It should prove that the state can be served by domestic brain drain.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:13 AM Author: Awkward nighttime location pervert
They can only admit so many people. Even if they rejected every single black peson that they admitted, 192 of those Asians would've still been rejected. Besides, why can't Berkeley practice a little yield protection too?
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:23 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
1,356 African American, Native American and Latino/Chicano students were admitted with scores below 1500 (Obviously many Asian Americans were also admitted with scores below this).
Your yield protection comment doesn't really stand up under analysis. Asian Americans with 1500+ have a 32.83% yield rate--which is not extremely far from Berkeley's normal yield rate. And believe me, yield rate is the LAST thing Berkeley should be worrying about at this point. If they can get their SAT average together first, maybe then can they think of such luxuries.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:31 AM Author: swashbuckling apoplectic principal's office
I don't see why the SAT average at present is such a huge problem. It's on an upward trend, after a few years of monkeying with admissions. Granted, it could be higher, but unfortunately the school is limiting itself largely to the CA applicant pool. Considering the size of the school, the SAT metrics aren't all that bad. The GPAs and class ranks are outstanding.
Date: November 18th, 2004 2:39 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
41.3% last year--like I said, doesn't stray too far from the figure (at least not enough to make a substantial impact on the yield numbers--the yield MAY have gone from 38% to 41.3% as a result but is this anywhere NEAR worth the result?...in any event, yield isn't even a metric in USNWR anymore, though I still think it's a worthy metric to strive for high marks in).
Date: November 18th, 2004 12:26 PM Author: tan stirring cuckold
And you don't really hear blacks protesting about their lack of representation on squash teams, in equestrian competitions, or in the world of opera music. Is it really that difficult to see how minor these things are compared to education? Less than 1% of the population will ever qualify to play on the NBA, whereas it is the goal of a large percentage of the population to obtain a quality education.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:05 AM Author: Obsidian abusive knife school cafeteria
Seems like that would just encourage top students to consider other options. Afterall, if you got a 1450+ on your SATs, would you really want to bother taking ANOTHER admissions exam?
Date: November 18th, 2004 4:03 AM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Yup. It was College Board's way of eliminating the possibility of UC jumping ship and taking with it a ton of revenue. This is seriously garbage though--one of the three major changes is merely the addition of an altered SAT II Writing section to the SAT I.
Date: November 18th, 2004 11:15 AM Author: Buck-toothed Son Of Senegal Point Subject: 209-based black underrepresentation will never end, I fear.
Meaning: to the extent Prop. 209 is adhered to (and, as noted by others above, it's not--at least not strictly), lower numbers for black students will continue. This will not change in the foreseeable future.
Note that this is *independent* of family income/educational background.
www.lagriffedulion.f2s.com/testing.htm
Thus I don't think calls for beefing up K-12 programs will "cure" the underrepresentation.
NB: I'm told that the link above is to an article on a racist site. I'm not familiar with the site itself, but this particular article seemed pretty straightforward. In any case, no need to wade through the whole article; just look at Figures 3 and 4.
I just don't believe that. I just don't. I refuse to accept that if we prioritize education **across the board** for young black children and their parents that there will not be a slow but persistent rise in representation at the UCs. I'm not saying this will be quick or easy; I am saying that with this change it will be inevitable.
There is nothing inherent in being black that keeps one from succeeding at the same level as anyone else. Remove the environmental and societal impedients (again, not easy tasks) and they will succeed.
And if in the long run we don't get the representation when we're at parity w/r/t qualified students, then we'll have to do to the East Asians and whites what the East Asians did to the whites: be undeniably better than them academically. But for now, parity'd be nice.
Good, so (while you're doing that) let's also do away with the frightening disparity in academic and extracurricualr resources and education guidance that exists between (predominantly minority) inner-city schools and their suburban counterparts.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:40 PM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Agreed. The issue of the politicians who pander to Latino and African American voters see AA as an easy solution because it costs them very little political capital, appeases the URM voters AND allows them to cast themselves in a social justicey light. Nobody wants to spend the kind of time, effort, energy and political capital necessary to push through reforms of K-12.
i simply don't understand what this sort of protest is supposed to accomplish. the problem is the dearth of competitive black applicants, exacerbated by the difficulty inherent to wooing them away from other schools. their time would have been better spent tutoring local hs students, helping them prepare college applications, etc.
It's a vicious cycle. Many of them don't want to come because they know there aren't many there to begin with. I've heard that it's quite difficult for blacks at Berkeley--being the last lab partner picked, etc.
However, the answer to this lies in K-12 education, and a change in blacks' cultural approach to education. Asians have always placed education first, which is why they are where they are.
I'm not so sure that I would recommend Berkeley to black students either. As a student, I love this place. As a black person, there's much to be desired.
Because the black population is sooo small, it seems that there is one "image" being put out there. The problem is that if your dress, speech, or mannerisms don't fit in with that group, you can't be in the community. And if they do, then you're marginalized by the rest of the campus that would prefer to see you gone.
I can honestly say (and I did not expect this to happen) that I've never felt so disconnected with blacks as I have during my stay here.
EDIT: And this isn't to say that I don't relate to or can't be friends with blacks who dress or act "thuggish." That's what was so great about high school; after the first few months, no one really cared.
I've always thought there has been general openness to blacks at Berkeley. Most people seem to understand they're underrepresented, and I figure most would also like to see their numbers go up.
The fact that many of the crimes committed around the Oakland/Berkeley area, including the beating of a student just yesterday, are perpetrated by young urban blacks can't help, I imagine.
If people can't understand the difference between random people on the street from rough neighborhoods and their fellow students, then maybe BAMN and the BRRC are correct in asserting that Berkeley is a hotbed of racism.
I'm sure they can tell the difference, but it's sometimes difficult to overcome stereotypes. Furthermore, the fact that admitted blacks at Berkeley do, on average, have much lower academic numbers than other admits can't help.
Ultimately, respect comes from performance. The black community, unfortunately, is still more into making excuses than actually performing. It's about priorities. You're telling me that you're an inner city black kid who can buy $100 Nikes but not afford a $12.95 SAT prep book?
Date: November 18th, 2004 4:51 PM Author: Hairless amber trailer park famous landscape painting
It's not always about affording the SAT prep book -- it's about having adults around who know how important that SAT book is and will put the screws on the kid to work on it. Most of the white and Asian kids aren't born highly motivated to sit around filling out test bubbles; they're being pushed by their parents, who have the time, information, and inclination to do the pushing. So I agree with you that it's partly about priorities, but I blame adults, not kids.
I think you took my message a little too literally. I place the blame on black culture, and that means adult culture. Of course it's the parents' fault.
They're the ones who should instill the value that the prep book is a better investment for the future than the bling-bling basketball shoes.
What contributes to this is that in order to put pressure on the administration to meet their desires (speaking in generalities, ot simply about AA) blacks must present a unified voice, because their simply aren't that many to begin with. In presenting this unified voice, diversity of thought within the black community must unfortunately be silenced.
Putting pressure on the administration, however, won't really help their cause. What blacks on campus should really be doing is putting the word out to prospective black students about Berkeley, and strongly encouraging admitted students to enroll--whether they feel it from the heart or not. The yield on admitted black students must go up, at least temporarily, to get things jump started.
Date: November 18th, 2004 3:47 PM Author: federal thriller blood rage
What's interesting, though, is that Berkeley's African American yield rate is 45.9%--higher than its overall yield rate. So I don't necessarily agree that upping efforts to attract admitted students to enroll will have a profound effect. Do you expect Berkeley to compete with Stanford- and Harvard-level black yield rates (in 2002, 64.4% at Stanford and 61.2% at Harvard)? There's no way this will happen.
Date: November 18th, 2004 4:41 PM Author: federal thriller blood rage
Please. There is no way that Berkeley can compete with H and S, etc. in terms of yield rate. When it comes to measures of input factors for the UG program, Berkeley is firmly entrenched in the category with UCLA and USC.
Date: November 18th, 2004 4:53 PM Author: Hairless amber trailer park famous landscape painting
Especially given the extremely generous financial aid offered by S & H; not many people would argue that it's cost-effective to choose Berkeley if it's more expensive, and for many black kids, it will be.
Date: November 18th, 2004 5:13 PM Author: Hairless amber trailer park famous landscape painting
Depends on what your income is...if your family makes the U.S. median or below, Harvard is free. A disturbingly large percentage of black kids grow up in households below the median.