Date: June 20th, 2012 5:23 PM Author: Narrow-minded ultramarine stag film wrinkle
Fairly obvious little breh. Allowing massive amounts of guns into Mexico increases the crime and miserableness of the general population who become even more motivated to illegally enter united states. This coupled with lax voter id and immigration policies allows for an influx of Hispanic voters.
Finally, Obama can say that he tried to allow for less gun control but the overall increased violence on the border (that seeps into the us) has forced his hand and he will then institute more stringent gun laws.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:12 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
This is all conservative talk radio is. There's nothing particularly noteworthy about the craziness of this theory.
The craziness is punctuated by ads for impotence drugs, CDs that teach you how to get-rich-by-flipping-houses, gold, and services for tax cheats. Seriously, that's easily 90% of the advertising clients.
The whole industry is impotent, dumb men appealing to impotent, lazy, gullible, dishonest men. The demographic is depressingly huge though.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:20 PM Author: harsh location
there was a lulzy ad about owing more than 10K CC debt and how the hopey changey stuff isn't working out for you so call this debt consolidation firm for help
The pre-2009 program, Operation Wide Receiver was shut down after attempts to monitor the guns had failed. Fast and Furious was restarted with knowledge of the prior program's failure and no real effort to track the guns. Plus, no one perjured themselves in connection with Operation Wide Receiver,.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:29 PM Author: Emerald buck-toothed trailer park dragon
Is there anything to suggest that gunwalking is anything but an ill-conceived bottom-up enforcement strategy (as opposed to some bizarre top-down politically motivated decision)?
I'm not a shitlib, but I'm having difficulty seeing how this was some sort of huge failure on Obama's part.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:31 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Nothing except for the recent announcement, issued on behalf of the sitting President of the United States, that all of the documents Congress is seeking in connection with its investigation into this policy/program are being withheld on the basis of Executive Privilege.
Either he was involved with it and can claim Executive Privilege over these documents (and should rightfully be subject to intense public scrutiny for its failure), or he wasn't and in spite of being a fucking former Constitutional Law professor he's now trying to assert a very narrow privilege to shield documents that clearly are not protected.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:38 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
There's no "maybe" about that, but as a strictly legal matter Obama can't have it both ways. Either he was involved with the program and can potentially claim the privilege now or he wasn't and he can't.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:36 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Let me ask you a question: do you have any idea what the term 'Executive Privilege' actually means as a legal matter, or are you just sort of going off the cuff here and giving us your personal opinion about what you think it should mean, like the white Rastafarian on the streetcorning bitching about how his pot use is, like, totally protected under the First Amendment, mon.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:46 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
What is the big objection to this? I assume the rationale was that the cartels are going to kill people regardless of what FBI does, so we might as well try to get some intelligence from the murder weapons. That makes a little bit of sense to me.
But why the outrage? Why are the NRA and Ted Nugent making this seem like a gun control issue?
Arming a next door apolitical army that controls vast financial resources is very, very dangerous for our stability. You clearly have no idea what these people are capable of and how big their networks are. They don't come with the type of baggage and restrictions that a sovereign does.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:11 PM Author: Talented idea he suggested
Lol at this ridiculous narrative. The cartels buy these guns everyday by the fucking boatload from crooked gun stores and gun shows in the US. This operation did not in any way put guns in the hands of those who would have never been able to obtain such weapons otherwise.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:13 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Solid defense, I'll be sure to raise it next time I'm prosecuted for selling the Crips a box of handguns with the serial numbers filed off. Sounds like a legal winner to me.
some of these people have seriously lost their minds trying to apologize for anything the Obama administration does. This unquestioned loyalty is mind-boggling.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:18 PM Author: Talented idea he suggested
Well if you're a law enforcement agency engaged in a sting operation you'd have a defense. I'm merely responding to the ridiculous claims that the DOJ and FBI are now responsible for the continuing violence in Mexico.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:21 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
So the FBI's motivation here is that of an illegal gun merchant? Haven't you totally disregarded the entire purpose of the program -- i.e., to hopefully obtain useful information about the illegal gun distribution network between US and Mexico?
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:26 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
I genuinely believe that you and TBF are either doltish or flame at this point. What don't I get here? (I mean that earnestly, as I'd like to understand the issue here; I've been tuning out for months and figure it's a good time to get up to date).
the program was halted after its initial intention (to gather intel) was failing. It started up again in 2009 and has since turned into something much worse, including money laundering operations et al.
Seriously read up before you come to xoxo and defend something you admit you don't even understand. Some of us actually spend our professional lives analyzing risk.
he's starting back up a program his predecessor ABANDONED because it was achieving unintended consequences. The Obama administration sees those unintended consequences as potentially politically favorable, and so, with notice of what those consequences are, re-launched and souped up the program that initially nobody back in 2006 predicted at least publicly would result in such a disaster.
imagine a hypothetical pacifistic scientist who in the course of his work discovered something that had vast and deadly destructive military applications and thus he abandons the work out of fear that Pandora's box would be opened if he were to continue. Then somebody else comes along later and discovers his findings and "continues" the work with the purpose of achieving those exact military applications.
let me preempt you and say don't misunderstand me and strawman and say I'm trying to equate bush to a pacifistic either, fuckwad. Likewise, the above analogy would be giving Obama as the second guy much too much credit. He's doing this for personal political gain, not nationalistic power.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:50 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
I understand the theory, I just find it incredible. Don't get me wrong, I think "Obama administration discovers that FBI can put guns in hands of drug cartels and contribute indirectly to border violence, in the process heightening political support for gun control among border Latinos (possibly further cementing Latino-Democrat alliance)" is a coherent theory. I just think it's exceedingly unlikely, as a factual matter, to have crossed the administration's mind. Our disagreement seems to boil down to our differing degrees of credulousness.
the second part of your summation is all wrong/completely bogus/typical Rush Limbaugh nonsense. He's doing it because there is a group of deep pockets whose only collective political interest for whatever reason is in making sure drugs stay illegal, which for Obama requires little concession or expenditure of political capital to do.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:27 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
Yes, I am the stupid guy who does NOT think that obama made the conscious decision to trade guns for laundered SuperPac donations of cartel blood money.
not something as stupid and obvious as campaign or superpac donations. You dont think the admin could have use for untraceable funds? you dont think there have been prior administrations that used narcodollars to fund regime change operations in other parts of the world? you act like there's never been precedent for anything like this before (iran-contra). ok go on your with life. i've wasted enough of mine on yours.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:35 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
LOL. Is the cartel comping orange juices for Mahliah while on vacation in Cancun? Or sending bags of cash to Chicago for Rahm Emanuel to launder for Barry? What are the non-campaign "personal gain[s]" Obama gets from the drug cartels in their capacity as "deep-pocketed donors"?
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:37 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
PS: Holder, Obama's AG, has repeatedly denied knowledge relating to activities conducted under this program at various points when he had a legal duty to speak truthfully in the past, and the Congressional investigation is now trying to go back and determine what he actually knew and when he knew it. Of course, that has absolutely nothing to do with either the arguable merits of the program as it was run under Obama or anything the Bush Administration did at all.
You're really not letting your profound ignorance on this topic stop you from authoritatively weighing in and dismissing everyone else as idiots, huh?
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:46 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
(Guy who doesn't think it's doltish to come in acting like a MFE when he doesn't know shit... just as long as in between the posts where he opines authoritatively he slips in a few oblique admissions that he doesn't actually know what he's talking about)
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:34 PM Author: Soggy Business Firm
they're just trying to avoid the issue that the main objective of the investigation now is to nab Eric Holder for perjury i.e. it's a witch hunt.
The program was bad, everyone admits it. But accountability here is merely firing people and the GOP see an opportunity to get Obama because he didn't fire Holder.
It's the same program done under Bush just larger and with some hindsight. But at its base level it's clearly stupid. The DOJ shouldn't have started it at any time. Their reconciliation is focusing on Holder since he's Obama's man.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:42 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
"i.e. it's a witch hunt"
Yes, how stupid and petty of Congress/the American people to be concerned that a high-ranking federal official might have straight up lied about his knowledge of a controversial government-sanctioned program while he was under oath. Who the fuck would possibly care about that, or think that if true, that sort of (illegal) behavior is deeply troubling and casts strong doubt on his fitness to serve as one of the most powerful lawyers in America... let alone even retain his bar membership? What a shameful partisan witch hunt, you are clearly so objective about all of this bro.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:00 PM Author: Soggy Business Firm
when your opponent does shit like funnel money to death squads so they could overthrow their government when Congress specifically tells them not to, you've always got to be on your tippy toes.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:14 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Well hell, now that I think about it, Nixon didn't know about the break-in until after the fact... no biggie! Fucking Democrats making a big deal about nothing.
It is unethical, period, to sell someone you know is a criminal a gun and then let him walk away to do what he will with it. It's even more appalling that the government would do it. An ethical prosecutor should not bring a case knowing that this sort of law enforcement tactic was used, and that's what the U.S. Attorneys did regarding the pre-2009 program.
It's the same reason we have the exclusionary rule and require warrants for wiretapping. We don't pursue law enforcement without any ethical boundaries.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:03 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
I, like most Americans, aren't too worried about the due process rights of Los Zetas. It's really more of a quasi-military intelligence operation than a run-of-the-mill law enforcement matter. If the FBI could get good info that leads to future prosecutions of persons in the US funneling weapons to the cartels, then I'm all for it. (Though I'm not quite sure how the exclusionary rule would apply in that case).
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:52 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Are you really asking why it's a big deal when we find out that the Executive Branch of the federal government was secretly selling deadly weapons to para-military groups that are comprised of psychopaths engaging in illegal activity, across national borders, that sometimes kills American civilians/law enforcement officials?
And why, to gun owners, this might be further exacerbated by the fact that the Administration under which this was carried out is made up of members of a political party that has long been openly hostile to private gun ownership and has often cited rising rates of drug-related gun violence as a prime justification for imposing tighter restrictions on gun ownership/use?
Yeah man I can't help you, I'm stumped too. Sorry.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:03 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
*Spends the week trying to take away the rights of private, law-abiding American citizens to own firarms for self-protection in violation of the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution*
*Spends weekends secretly selling firearms to Mexican criminals with the knowledge and expectation that they will turn around and use them to violently smuggle things across the American border in violation of countless federal laws*
"What's the big deal, bro? Fucking reptiles always getting pissed off about some ol' bullshit, man."
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:57 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
The second story is just delusional. Obama is trying to ban guns by arming Mexican drug gangs? No serious person believes that.
And as for the first one, it's a closer call. Maybe it was unethical. If they supplied, say, 0.3% of the firearms used by the dealers but in the process garnered key clues that exposed the distribution chains for smuggled drugs and weapons, then I imagine most Americans would be ok with that. I certainly would. Especially if FBI uses information to take out key links in the chain, frustrating ability of cartels to access the other 99.7% of their weapons.
I suspect that is why Mukasey and Holder both liked the idea.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:12 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
PS: Obama was the one who raised legal questions about the scope of his own *personal* involvement in this *by invoking Executive Privilege over all of these documents*, genius. Even if only kooks were pointing figures and raising eyebrows at him before, that's certainly not the case now.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:19 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
Dumb. This story has been on front burner for conservatives for months now. I'm trying to figure out why. If your answer is "because Obama is engaged in a convoluted conspiracy to eradicate hunting from Michigan's upper peninsula," you'd better have better evidence than "he invoked executive privilege yesterday".
It's like I am arguing with a truck driver calling into Glenn Beck's program.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:26 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
My answer to that for rational, intelligent conservatives is "See Point #1, above." The government's involvement in this is res ipsa alarming, and we would be crazy not to dig into it further now that it's come to light. My answer to that for the crazier, kookier gun-nuts is "See Points #1 and #2, above." (Although presidential involvement in 'outrageous conspiracies', at least ex post, is hardly unprecedented in modern times, in case you didn't know.)
You might not be personally impressed by the import of either of those concerns, but when it comes to whether or not this Administration is legally obligated to turn over documents pursuant to Congressional subpoena, then that's not exactly the relevant legal standard for deciding the issue now is it? And when Obama himself invokes Executive Privilege - a privilege that has been *very* narrowly construed by SCOTUS w/r/t written documents, something that we can and should assume that Obama, as a former Con Law professor at a top law school, would be well aware of - and refuses to hand over the documents on that ground, I think it's objectively rational and not at all crazy to wonder why the hell he is doing that and to seek clarification instead of just going "Oh yeah of course, sure carry on we trust you bro."
Given how brilliant you seem to think you are as you dismissively equate everything that I'm saying to the loony ramblings of a 90 IQ trucker, it's amazing how you have completely failed to actually engage with, let alone rebut, any of the substance of these points (and also how you clearly had no idea what "Executive Privilege" actually was to begin with in spite of acting like a MFE on that topic, but I'm sure you were just joshing.)
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:40 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
This is a fair post. I just don't get the hemming and hawing. Like I said, #1 seems like we're having a genuine law enforcement policy disagreement. But it's goofy to get all excited about the program and compare the FBI to an illegal arms dealer that is complicit in killing a bunch of people. I just don't see it that way. And as for #2, I do think it's crazy talk. I'll just leave it at that.
The subpoena issue is a different issue. I think Obama thinks Issa is a venal, contemptuous gnat and he is playing chicken with him.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:52 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
I don't feel strongly about the conspiracy theory stuff - I don't personally buy into it, but enough crazy shit has happened in recent history (Nixon, Iran Contra) that I wouldn't be totally mindblown if there was some element of truth to it, either. I think there are ample grounds for an investigation, I think it's more than likely that Eric Holder commited perjury, and I think Obama is acting shady for some reason or another now.
I also think that if Obama thinks that "playing chicken" with Executive Privilege in the face of a Congressional subpoena issued as part of an ongoing perjury investigation against the AG is wise or appropriate, he's far, far dumber than I would have ever guessed - both as a legal matter and as a political matter, because this just makes him look unnecessarily shady too and will make it much more difficult for him to distance himself from anything that goes down/gets uncovered.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:03 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
This makes sense. Seems to me this is the real meat-and-potatoes of conservative anger: "Eric Holder lied to me!"
It's a serious charge. But the crocodile tears over the guns in the hands of the cartels is just the background, not the thing itself. There could be a memo to the effect of "We need to keep program confidential because FOX will run with it if it becomes public knowledge" that Holder didn't want out there. Or maybe he did lie about it thinking the issue would go away.
Date: June 20th, 2012 6:13 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Yes, Conservatives en masse tend to hate Holder for a variety of reasons, some of which I think are pretty legitimate. They might make a fuss about the background on this, but at the end of the day all that matters is that they have him between a rock and a hard place and they are on the right side of the law.
What's frustrating is that so many liberals like solace and wallace ITT - and bearing in mind that self-described liberals are the ones who are supposed to be particularly suspicious of 'authoritarian bootlickers', who are supposed to be particularly critical and questioning of those who "hold the power", etc. - seem to want to waive their hands and dismiss this all, just because Holder is Obama's man and they looooove them some Obama. All of these eye-rolling comparisons to Clinton... all of this smokescreening about how F&F started under Bush... all of the snickers at the Nugent et al freakshow... it's incredibly disingenuous, and if these fgts had any real principles they would be leading the charge to investigate Holder and nail his ass to the wall based on the mounting evidence that he lied about his knowledge of a controversial secret government program that ended up killing an American law enforcement agent, regardless of the fact that he's a Democratic appointee. Instead they reveal themselves to be mindless partisan shills, making them look all the more hypocritical when they try and pick up the banner of high-minded idealism.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:40 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
Like Watergate, at this point this isn't so much about what actually happened on the ground (fucked up though that was) as it is about figuring out when the relevant political figures actually knew what, at one point, they outright denied having any knowledge about.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:54 PM Author: Emerald buck-toothed trailer park dragon
Who gives a shit? Gov't is gonna do what it do. Fuckups happen. It doesn't seem like there is any possible untoward motivation.
A shitstorm is warranted, but if you think some sort of doc is going to surface with Obama's imprimatur on it saying something like "Make sure dis AR-15 makes its way over to Carlos", you're probably going to be disappointed.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:57 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
"It doesn't seem lke there is any possibly untoward motivation"
You are seriously flame or stupid, there is no third alternative.
"A shitstorm is warranted"
...and if by 'a shitstorm' you mean 'a release of the requested papers to Congress or thorough and complete explanation of exactly why, as a legal matter, the invocation of Executive Privilege is warranted with regard to the requested papers', then yes. And given that neither have been forthcoming in the months that this investigation has been proceeding, anyone who isn't flame or an idiot (see above, e.g., not you) can probably see why some people are understandably MAF about the current situation.
But on the off chance that you're a lawyer, be sure to respond to the next legally legitimate RFPs that you receive that are clearly designed to fish for smoking gun documents with a terse explanation that "it's really unlikely that those sort of documents exist, so fuck off I'm not digging up any files for you." That's totally the way these things work, if you just alpha them around like that these pussy plaintiffs counsels usually feel dumb as fuck for even asking and might even settle.
agreed. no need to formulate a theory about secret motives when plain old stupidity explains the facts.
the conservatards who obsess over this issue say that Obama told anti-gun people that he was working on some things "under the radar" and so F&F, coupled with the supposed cover-up, looks to them like a deep conspiracy. the invocation of executive privilege, when Obama says he learned of F&F only through the news, will make the conspiracy nuts obsess even more.
Date: June 20th, 2012 4:21 PM Author: fragrant place of business fortuitous meteor
There was a show on Patriot Radio (Sirius) that was dedicated entirely to Fast and Furious. This guy would spend 2 hours every night just discussing Fast and Furious. It was so weird.
No one died in Watergate, and yet we investigated the shit out of that. In this case, an innocent border patrol agent died because of DOJ's lack of ethics AND incompetence.
Date: June 20th, 2012 5:21 PM Author: Poppy Menage
To be fair,
I read this post, and yet why am I so skeptical that you similarly thought that all of the inquiries into the Bush Administration's shady dealings were "a ridiculous waste of time"?