Walker Percy famously answered the question of alternatives to Catholicism with a counter-question: "What else is there?"
When an interviewer pressed him on how belief is possible in the modern age and listed alternatives—such as atheism, humanism, agnosticism, materialism, Marxism, astrology, theosophy, and metaphysics—Percy replied, "That is what I mean. What else is there?"
Why Percy Saw Few Real Alternatives
• Modern alienation: Percy viewed modern society as fractured by mind-body alienation ("angelism" and "bestialism") and spiritual malaise.
• Limits of secularism & scientism: He argued that scientific humanism, materialism, and expert-driven culture fail to answer human longing or give words like "sin" and "grace" real meaning.
• Sacramental realism: After converting to Catholicism in 1947, Percy found meaning in ordinary, incarnational reality—such as language, relationships, and the sacraments—rather than abstract systems or pure consumption.