Date: February 10th, 2009 11:39 AM Author: Federal Jewess
The NY state legislature will impose an additional 10% tax rate on those making more than $1 million and raise state taxes to around 8% for those making more than 250K. So if you're making more than 250, you'll pay more than 50% of your income in taxes.
Date: February 10th, 2009 11:57 AM Author: Turquoise Vibrant Digit Ratio
yeah, it's ridiculous. cook county has the highest sales tax in the country. the president of the board of county commissioners lobbied successfully to raise it from just under 10% to fund a bunch of Blago-style nonsense (like a private elevator to his office and whatnot).
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:01 PM Author: Black piazza
No, that sales tax is a LOT worse.
I don't give a fuck about the whole NYC vs. Chicago shit you try to stir up (although, personally, I'm not a fan of the Chi), but this isn't even a close one. I'll take the city tax over an 11% sales tax any day. 11% is fucking outrageous.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:04 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
That's silly. Buy stuff out of state/internet and you don't pay. The sales tax doesn't apply on food either. City tax just kills you. NYC may have a ton of great stuff going for it but the tax situation makes living in NYC basically a no-go.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:07 PM Author: Black piazza
Maybe it's silly, or maybe it's just psychological -- I don't even think about the taxes that come out of my check because I'm still making enough that I'm not sweating it. My paycheck is what it is. But getting hit for 11% every time I want to go shopping, or go to a game, or whatever, I don't know that would get to me. Maybe it's just because I spend a lot of money.
Although if it's not on food/beverages I guess that makes it more tolerable, since that's where a lot of my money goes.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:15 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
Its clearly psychological because the math doesn't add up. The fact is that there is no way you're going to pay an extra $12K+ in extra sales tax if you make any effort to shop online, outside the city, etc. Plus, everything is generally cheaper in Chicago, especially housing. There are great things about NYC, but I wouldn't try to stand toe to toe with Chicago on value for money - because its not even close. I recall working biglaw, living in a decent apartment that cost me $3K/month (but would cost 1/2 to 1/3 in Chicago or Houston), and after taxes and loans I had very little left over. In Chicago I recall living as a student and feeling like I had more disposable income.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:18 PM Author: Black piazza
Oh don't get me wrong, I know that I'm paying a premium just to live in the city.
But at the same time, I can afford to (even moreso now that my girl has moved in) so what's the big deal? This place is fucking awesome and I'd say it's worth it. Yes you could live in Jersey or something but I'll pay for the convenience of midtown Manhattan and not think twice. But that's me.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:22 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
Different strokes for different folks. But its a pretty huge premium, and one that impacts your lifestyle, both in the short and long term. And seriously, I love NYC. I just can't justify living in the city.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:23 PM Author: Federal Jewess
Yeah, there's nothing wrong with liking NYC. But the premium is just not worth it, given the fact that you can get pretty much the same thing in other cities but at half the price.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:27 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
I don't think anyone is denying this. The trouble is that most of us are ambitious professionals and primarily pick where we live based on our jobs. For the sort of work I do I'm basically going to be in NYC, maybe DC, London, E. Europe, Hong Kong, or some other big, expensive city. Chicago isn't very realistic (aside from which, I absolutely hate that city), and neither is Houston. Often times the choice is more "live in NJ and suffer the inconvenience for more cash, or live in NYC and pay up..."
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:35 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
There are (were, anyway) plenty of great jobs that paid far more for similar or lower hours. Bankers, lawyers, consultants, all did very well. Of course, we're all getting raped out here now and regretting it...
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:27 PM Author: Black piazza
Well it's not impacting my lifestyle in the short term -- if I want to do something, i do it (though maybe I don't have the most extravegant tastes). Long term remains to be seen, but I've saved more money to this point that I thought I would when I started this gig 3+ years ago and it's not like I'm planning on having kids or anything (now *there* is a financial drain).
But the bigger issue, at least to me, is that I get to live in this city. I really love it. And it is only made all the more sweeter when I see people who can't hack it/afford it start threads like this. On some level it makes me feel special to know that others are so jealous of what I have.
You're right though, different strokes. If stacking loot is a top priority then there are definitely better places to live than Manhattan.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:51 PM Author: Dashing casino philosopher-king
"Well it's not impacting my lifestyle in the short term -- if I want to do something, i do it (though maybe I don't have the most extravegant tastes)."
That's kind of it - realistically, you could get much more in other places and save more at the same time.
"Long term remains to be seen, but I've saved more money to this point that I thought I would when I started this gig 3+ years ago and it's not like I'm planning on having kids or anything (now *there* is a financial drain)."
Agreed, hence same approach here (no kids). But the truth is that one could save up far more and retire earlier.
"And it is only made all the more sweeter when I see people who can't hack it/afford it start threads like this. On some level it makes me feel special to know that others are so jealous of what I have."
While ordinarily I wouldn't condone your primitive, typical frat-boyish self-congratulatory public verbal masturbation, JJC can't but help make anyone who lives in NYC feel that way. I mean, sure, people can think that NYC isn't worth the price of admission, but at the point where someone constantly obsesses over it they're just making NYCers feel even better. Its like the kids who used to post dozens of threads on game forums when the PS3 came out and cost like $1K+ (due to availability) all proclaiming that they would NEVER get a PS3, not even if it was free.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:12 PM Author: Turquoise Vibrant Digit Ratio
i have no idea. I just read a lot about Bloomberg's bizarre efforts at maximizing city revenue by creating a bunch of specialty taxes and whatnot. I'm not judging. Daley and Stroger are cash whores too (like, there is a proposal on the table to make all parking meters $6/hr).
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:15 PM Author: Federal Jewess
The Chicago specialty taxes don't bother me as much because it affects a subgroup of people ie. those who drive. I don't have a car, so it's not really a big deal.
NYC, on the other hand, have massive taxes on income, which affects everyone and has a deleterious effect on the city's economic growth.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:21 PM Author: Turquoise Vibrant Digit Ratio
i don't know the tax code in NYC that well. I know that, not including sales tax, someone like me in Chicago (homeowner in a fairly low tax bracket without a car) pays about 33% of my gross income to the government before refunds. add on sales tax (which also applies to food), and we're probably paying taxes at a rate of under 40% of gross income. not sure how this stacks up against everywhere else, though.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:05 PM Author: Federal Jewess
Between the two cities, there's no question that NYC people get screwed more by their government. They pay high taxes to live in a city that can't even clean up their fucking streets, and pay outrageous rent to live in apartments that would pass as a housing project in most other cities.
Date: February 10th, 2009 11:56 AM Author: Federal Jewess
Texas rocks. After Chicago and LA, Dallas is my favorite city.
NYC is for liberal losers who enjoy giving most of their money to the government, just so they can attend opera, broadway shows, and art gallery parties.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:08 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
uh, i live in austin and there are cabs circling the areas where people go out. there are also FREE services that take drunks home in their own cars, paid for by hippies against drunk driving or something.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:26 PM Author: Effete blood rage
You TX trolls are always the same. Whenever NY or Chicago or any other city in a state besides TX pops up, you have to mention 'no state income tax' as if that's the only thing people care about. Maybe some people would rather deal with state income tax than live in TX?
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:36 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
this is the first time i can recall saying anything about the income tax. and i only post here during the day, and not very frequently. how are you so angry about tx trolls, when many people on here are trolls for one place or another?
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:37 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
You're kind of JJCish about this. And he's, you know, flame.
Most other people can kind of accept that even though they love some place, there might be some reasons other people wouldn't like it or might prefer to live somewhere else.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:42 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
i don't post on here much. we just both happened to be in several similar threads about this. when TMF wasn't able to understand why anyone would want *anythnig* different from what he wanted, you insisted he was truly a good guy. why is it such a big deal if i pop in here sometimes and post an adverse opinion? like i said, i'm not on here that much (only during the day, and on some days not at all or only for a handful of posts), and this wouldn't have turned into a 50 post thread if my 3 word comment about income tax had just been ignored. if what the other posters are saying is true and texas trolls are always mentioning the income tax, just ignore it.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:57 PM Author: exciting circlehead garrison
LOL no. I skim long chains to see if people are talking about something interesting.
If you look carefully you'd notice I almost never respond to you.
For the record, Texas is full of annoying shitheads like you. No income tax is not worth the trade off of being around someone like you all day at work.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:59 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
i'm actually an east coaster, having spent 90% of my life on the east coast or the northeast. and yes, east coasters are insufferable people compared to people who've lived in the south or texas most of their life.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:49 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
Oh, TMF can be pretty impossible about sex and gender roles. And yeah, he's also a pretty good guy. I don't think you're a bad person either, just that you're miserable to discuss things with.
It's not your opinion I object to. It's the fact that you can't seem to make any allowances for differening ones. The cold weather thread where you kept ranting on how places where it gets cold in the winter must be completely unlivable, when people can and do live there, and have for millenia, is kind of what I mean.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:54 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
the only thing i find difficult to understand is why people would live in places that are like arctic tundra for half the year. denver, i love. alaska, however, seems like a nightmare. you actually have to worry about whether your children are getting enough sunlight. and i am not alone in this opinion. most people i know who live or lived in miserably cold places cited reasons that you mentioned, like family being there, or a job relocation. i rarely hear people say they moved to milwaukee because they just love the city.
Date: February 10th, 2009 1:00 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
People move to New York because they love the city all the time. Same with Boston. Same with Seattle. Personally, I'd rather live in Minneapolis than in most cities in the country. And I know several people who moved to Alaska for that reason - it's absolutely beautiful up there.
Milwaukee admittedly sucks, but it's not because of the weather.
Date: February 10th, 2009 1:11 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
i have never said that i can't comprehend why anyone would live in new york. i thought it was fun, short term. me posting "0% income tax" in this thread does not mean i should be lumped in with the incessant chicago is better than nyc trolls.
Date: February 10th, 2009 1:00 PM Author: Maize vigorous area police squad
Why is Alaska remotely relevant here? New York weather is not the same as Alaska. But there are still reasons people move to Alaska -- they like the remoteness, the outdoor activities, etc.
We get it, you don't like cold weather. I don't mind cold weather and would probably prefer living in a place with a fairly cold winter than a place that is warm the entire year. People generally don't move to Milwaukee because they "love the city" because it is a relatively small city that has been declining economically for decades. The cold weather is almost certainly a tertiary reason to that. Cities like Chicago and NYC are not remotely in the same category as Milwaukee in terms of lifestyle, culture, economic opportunity.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:29 PM Author: Aqua Lodge
everyone argues on here you dirty cunt but you have a smug attitude that rubs me the wrong way. Plus I get the distinct feeling sometimes you pick a fight just to be a haughty cum dumpster.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:38 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
um, i'm actually pretty quiet in real life. this board is filled with betas (both male and female) who come on here to get rowdy, act like an asshole, troll for one thing or another, post racist or sexist rants, and sling random insults at strangers, since they can't or won't in real life. eg: you.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:54 PM Author: Aqua Lodge
ooh, calling me a beta really hurt my feelings.
also, if you don't think I'm an asshole in real life, you are fooling yourself. If I was to ever meet you, I'm pretty sure I'd call you a fucking moron.
Date: February 10th, 2009 2:00 PM Author: Aqua Lodge
no because you think so highly of yourself. I think if I was to talk to you in a bar and I realized what an annoying stupid bitch you were I'd be willing to call you a moron.
Date: February 10th, 2009 2:05 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
i've encountered many people in all the places i've lived, and no one has ever called me annoying or a stupid bitch. most people who know me well like me, and those that don't know me well think i'm on the shy side. and no girl has to "think highly of herself" to suggest that random guy X is more likely to hit on them than call them a stupid bitch.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:13 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
There's more to culture than high culture. Most large cities have a symphony or an opera. A lot of cities don't have an active and varied live music scene, or a large number of free gallery shows, or things of that nature.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:17 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
most cities of decent size have an active live music scene. if my thing was live music, i'd rather be in a place like austin than an east coast city. tons of free shows and music festivals all year.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:20 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
No, most cities do not have much of a live music scene. Most have a handful of places where you can hear bands, and a smallish number of groups that play there. Austin is kind of an exception in that regard. Most cities also don't have much in the way of an art scene, a point I noticed you skipped.
And, somewhat related, New York (and a few similar cities) have a number of people who moved to the city in part because they want access to those things. Those people tend to have somewhat different interests than people who choose cities because of the weather or the outdoor activities - not that one's better or worse, but if you like the things in the first paragraph you'll probably find more compatible people in New York than in some other cities.
I mean, I know you like where you live, but when we've talked about things like weather in the past, you seem to have difficulty understanding why anyone would want to live anywhere in the northern part of the country. Is it really that hard to see that people value different things?
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:29 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
austin and other major texas cities also have numerous galleries, many with local artist's work as well as famous artists, free nights (or free all the time). i actually do many more cultural activities here than i did in either LA or NYC. in austin i have A) a lot more free time on my hands and B) a lot more money.
in those cold weather threads, other people pointed out that growth in really cold cities has become relatively stagnant ever since air conditioning became common. so it's not just me that's stopped wanting to live in cold citites. one of the first reasons you gave for why people may want to live in a freakishly cold city is because their family is there. that to me indicates that a good number of people wouldn't live in these cities if they weren't compelled to be there because of their parents or whoever.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:51 PM Author: Effete blood rage
Most are "best bang for your buck" type ratings. Are you such a dumb cunt that you can't understand that people want other things besides saving money? Sure I could shop at Walmart instead of Nordstrom's to save money. So what? There are certain things you can do in NY that are not available in TX. And the high cost of living may be worth it for some. And if you can't understand that, you a a dumb narrow-minded cunt.
I'm glad that you enjoy living where you do, but what is the point of trying to convince others that your state is the best? It's just fucking annoying. I don't care if you don't like NY or CA...don't live there. No one's trying to convince you. Anytime someone mentions 'cold weather' or 'income tax' you have to come in there and troll.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:59 PM Author: Effete blood rage
*sigh* You are just insufferable. If you are at all representative of what Texans are like, I am so fucking glad I don't live there. Have a great life, I'm done here.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:33 PM Author: Floppy resort hissy fit
Not nearly the same number, nor are there as many artists living in the area. As for free time and money, those seem to be specific to your situation.
I'm not arguing that no one wants to live in Texas. Obviously a number of people do. But you're talking here to people who have had every chance to live in Texas and have chosen not to. What's the point of trying to convince us that Texas is objectively better?
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:45 PM Author: Passionate chrome persian
i have more free time because law firms don't require as many hours of work from all levels of employee. i have more money because my salary is slightly higher and my bills are sliced in half. this isn't specific to my situation.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:48 PM Author: Maize vigorous area police squad
Great. Obviously free time and money are important considerations. These may be considerations that ultimately lead me away from NYC. They are not, however, the only considerations that matter in choosing a place to work and live.
Date: February 10th, 2009 12:17 PM Author: Federal Jewess
Plenty of cities have everything you mentioned, Rowan. I know you have to constantly justify living in a tiny shithole apartment in yorkville, so your ignorant comment will get a pass from me.
Date: February 11th, 2009 7:49 AM Author: free-loading honey-headed heaven
Texas's property tax rates are many times the average. I don't know what the net tax effect of effectively putting the income tax burnen on property owners is.
Date: February 10th, 2009 2:58 PM Author: exciting circlehead garrison
The New York trolls are so defensive about their expensive shithole apartments. It's like if they concede that the outrageous taxes, weather, people, etc etc etc suck they are admitting they chose a stupid place to live.
If you people truly like it then you wouldn't work so damn hard to defend it.
Date: February 10th, 2009 8:39 PM Author: Curious Primrose Main People
I've never been to Ann Arbor, but you can't seriously say that GRAND RAPIDS has "all the culture of a big city". The only thing of any cultural value that you can do in Grand Rapids is take the three-hour drive to Chicago.
I have been to GR several times (law school boyfriend moved there after graduation) and while it had some cultural offerings like most small cities do, it was, by no means, a cultural city.
It had the token concert hall and theater, but had nothing in the way of live music, comedy, jazz, or cultural diversity (no ethnic restaurants - even the waiter at a high-end Italian place pronounced it "EYE-talian"). There's a small bit of Dutch culture in the Meijer gardens, and a few Calder structures scattered about the cityscape but that's all.
The only thing redeeming about the city was that it had a lot of high-end furniture stores as a result of its former status as the "furniture capital of the world".
It is very much a place where white, upper-middle class fans of Jesus go to breed.
Date: February 11th, 2009 11:55 AM Author: chest-beating gold therapy knife
This is just a pack of lies that I need to rebut.
Practicing law in Michigan is a great thing to do.
You are right, Grand Rapids is close to Chicago. It's great for a weekend trip to the big city, but without living with all the disadvantages of somewhere like Chicago.
I wouldn't go so far as to call Grand Rapids a "small city", though. It's the second largest city in Michigan!
Grand Rapids is big enough to have it all, though. Museums, a world-class botanical garden, Frederik Meijer Gardens & Sculpture Park, plays, art galleries, John Ball Zoo, Public Museum, Children’s Museum, a Gerald R. Ford Presidential Museum and the first LEED Certified Art Museum in the world. It's also just the right size to allow for outdoor getaways to the beach, the countryside, orchards, skiing and parks.