I read this article as well. If you live in Chicago, you can grab the magazine for free.
So here are my thoughts. Chicago is a fine city with lots to offer, but lately, the incessant comparisons with NYC and various people writing silly articles claiming that Chicago has now surpassed NYC, is both annoying and delusional.
The author basically interviews several new yorkers who moved to Chicago, and makes the argument that wealthy new yorkers now see Chicago as a viable and even more desirable option than NYC. This reminds me of those idiots who claim that China has surpassed U.S. because of GDP growth, trade surplus, and better high school math/science education. I always tell people that I'll believe this when top U.S. university graduates flock to China to get their Phd's. Likewise, I'll belive Chicago has surpassed NYC, when it has more financial and fortune 500 firms, higher real estate value, more billionaires, and more international prestige, just to name a few.